Looks an awful lot like a moisture meter...
this post was submitted on 12 Sep 2023
58 points (96.8% liked)
Gardening
538 readers
1 users here now
founded 4 years ago
MODERATORS
Which also suck. My daughter bought one, and when I stick it into a glass of water it measures about 5 on a scale of 10. (1 being dry, 10 being wet.)
Apparently I could use more water in my water?
Your water probably wasn’t conductive enough. Try adding some salt to raise the ppm and it’ll read correctly. Wet soil is way more conductive than pure water.
Just tried, and with about 2 teaspoons of salt in a half cup of water it reads about 7, or just at the end of the "moist" but not quite "wet.". So better, but I think the meter just isn't all that accurate. (I don't think she paid much for this thing anyway... or at least I hope not.)
Almost any salt will work, actually. It could be table salt or any NPK salt that is used as fertilizer.
So, if there is a farmer that is really pissing you off, dump several hundred tons of NaCl on his fields. Nutrient spot tests might get temporarily fooled and everything will also die.
Remind me to never piss you off...
3 point scale! The longer you look the worse it gets
Brawndo meter, because Brawndo has what plants crave!
"Modern" farming looks sure like a lot of tech from the '80s to me.
Ok, this is a rough science and likely very inaccurate with the pictured device.
Different nutrients in soil can alter electrical signals passed between two or three different probes that are on these kinds of devices. That can be measured and approximate nutrient content can be calculated.
Proper nutrient testing summary: https://www.agrifarming.in/importance-of-nutrient-sensors-in-agriculture-advantages-and-working-principle
Since the pictured device is likely under $5, I would speculate that it has you wet the soil first before the probe is inserted. Nutrient salts can change the conductivity of water and it is trivial to amplify any change in resistance or capacitance on one of those types of needle meters. It only takes a tiny amount of current. The probes themselves could act as a battery of sorts, similar to how you can make a simple battery with a potato. (I would guess we are around 1mA or less with this setup.)
It's not a great solution, it's prone to false readings but its approximate enough for the home gardener. At the very least, you know the soil conductivity: More conductivity is sometimes better than less.
Edit: Looking at that picture, the soil doesn't look very wet to me. It could explain the "lack of nutrients".
It's not a great solution, it's prone to false readings but its approximate enough for the home gardener.
I have a small handful of plants. It's good enough for me. I completely agree that if it were my livelihood I would be sending it off to a lab. If something happens to my garden I get less salsa and have to buy tomatoes at the store. If something happens to a farm they're fucked for the year unless they get on top of it.
I haven't ever seen those nutrients sensors you link to, and I'm highly suspect. The closest thing I've seen are XRF guns and those are for metals.
The whole fertility sensor/probe thing is a pipe dream IMO. Soil heterogeneity is tremendous.
If you want an accurate reading, a lab is a must. Even then, parameters such as soil texture can vary by 10 to 30%
And electrical conductivity is never good. It's routinely screened for along with SAR
Oh, that $5 piece of crap is absolutely telling you a number that has very little value. If you use it properly and the needle pegs in one direction or another, you probably want to invest in a decent test. (Even pegging that needle doesn't mean much, TBH.)
ISM sensors are typically used in hydroponics for disolved O2 and are "decently" priced. The ones that are available for nitrates and such are generally considered lab equipment and are not cheap.
This meter is not for the application we are taking about, but it's close enough: https://www.hannainst.com/nitrate-photometer-hi97728.html
Totally agree. Send it to a lab if you need real results.
cities skylines level tweet
Wow. I wonder how many people have bought such a silly device.
There is a bunch of snake oil out there. I find it rather funny, and this is up there on my list.
Other ones include inducing negative ions into the soil through a copper wire wrapped around a sappling to change the 'charge' of the soil. (My soul just cried typing that).
Or the guy who was giving courses on soil homeopathy
So heres the thing with these devices, they aren't accurate but they are sort of precise.
Every soil is different, but the same soil at roughly the same wetness will fairly precisely read the same way each time.
So in conjunction with a much more accurate readout from lab equipment, you can get an initial handful of readings from your specific patch of land and record what this meter read, so you benchmark the actual spot you wanna hit with the dial for your very specific fertilizer comp you use. Say, mark it with a little marker.
Then for the rest of that season, this little meter should be pretty solid enough because you first took the time to calibrate it against more accurate tools
At which point its not a reader on its own, its merely a well calibrated gauge, calibrated against other tooling.
And that will work fairly well enough for most use cases. The point of the device isn't to track precisely getting your mixes right, the point is it will instantly point out if something has gone very wrong before it gets worse.
You change soil wetness, and it will show something completely different.
Too little or too much what? N? P? K? What about salinity?
But can't you see just look at the 1 2 3 an see if good or bad.
Whoop, meter is low, better call co-op and order one fertilizer, please
To be honest modern farming does work a lot like that
my snake oil meter is measuring too much
Something tells me this is just a nitrogen detector
3 nitrogen?
I guess somebody's bullshit detector isn't working.
so, is it just a pH meter with different labels?