I was standing up for this guy recently, arguing that having a donation page is fine. However, this goes way beyond donations and feels more like a sale.
this post was submitted on 24 Aug 2023
82 points (96.6% liked)
CrackWatch
3479 readers
1 users here now
IF YOU ARE NEW TO THIS FORUM, PLEASE READ THIS POST >>>>The Beginner's Guide<<<< IT WILL TAKE 2 MINUTES MAX, AND IT WILL ANSWER MOST OF YOUR QUESTIONS
Welcome to CrackWatch, a piracy news forum dedicated to informing the public about the latest cracks and bypasses.
To get live announcements of the latest releases, follow our Twitter
Rules
- No question threads. Read the beginners guide.
- Don't spam or post non-related posts. This includes NSFW.
- Do not use link shorteners
- Don't be rude, racist or sexist
- Linking directly to or requesting cracked games and software is not allowed.
- Follow the Posting Guideline
founded 1 year ago
MODERATORS
Eh, it's his code, his work. I believe he's within his rights to decide how he's compensated.
I personally think this method is a bad idea but then again I don't pay this game and don't even know what the mod does. Maybe it's the second coming or whatever and he knows his business more than I though. Either way, it's his right.
Not really. Modding is allowed, but as soon as you start making money over a game you don't own I expect Rocktar is gonna cease an desist him into oblivion. Yeah, it's his code... but without the game is useless. Donations are a thing, selling something you don't own the right to is another. Be aware, I don't want anything to do with that mod and I don't even know whst it is tbh
Legally, you might be right. I don't know; I'm not a lawyer and I don't care enough about this case to learn about it.
But I'm not talking about legalities here. I'm talking about calling this person's moral character into question because he decided to go this route, which I don't really agree with. I don't care that it is built on top of Rockstar's code. Everything is built on top of somebody else's code. Again, not talking legalities here; but I don't see a difference, and don't agree that Rockstar should even have a say in this. They should sit back and be thankful that somebody created whatever this is which might just sell them a few extra copies of the game through no investment of their own.
I don't like DRM. I don't like people charging money for what is built on top of FOSS. But I also think it's the creators' right to choose how they distribute their work. /shrug
The funniest part of this is how likely Rockstar is to yank the whole thing out from under him.
That has to be illegal right? Like building a mod for a game is fine but if you charge people for the mod for that game its illegal in most cases. This is effectively that.
Nope. His mods are his own code, and he has the right to sell it. I don't agree with what they're doing, but that's a separate conversation.
Heavily depends on how the mod interacts with the game. If it does not use anything that's from the game, selling stuff becomes against ToS at the best and illegal at the worst
While it may not use any assets from the game, it sure as hell uses asstes from Nvidia (?) that are required to enable DLSS3. But I don't know how they are licensed and if a sale is allowed...
Unfortuantly his code doesn't act independently of its own accord or through software that has permission either. Unless he has a deal with Rockstar (doubtful) they can claim this as a violation.
Ratlobber created a video on a Gmod mod that when pirated would leak your IP address. Kind of reminds me a bit of that.
I would link his video explaining and going over it I knew which one it was but his titles and actual descriptions are not very descriptive so I don't know which one it was.
Edit: Nevermind here's a link to the video
Oh and Rockstar partnering with cfx.re (the team behind FiveM and RedM). I feel like that'll mean more DRM in their work.
Modifications need to be free. Anyone paywalling mods is a traitor to the modding community and can fuck right off
I dunno man, I feel two kinds of ways about it.
i think people who work for the benefit of others without requiring payment is laudable
I also feel, as the working class child of a working class family, that fair pay for a day's work is equally as laudable.
at least, that is, until we reach a Star Trek utopia without money. but they had to go through the Resource Wars first themselves.
I totally understand this. But I feel like there are better ways to monetize work than this.
I absolutely respect modders that link sites like patreon or buymeacoffee and I have previously given money to modders who's mods I enjoyed (because they deserve it).
Modding should work as a community effort. By paywalling a mod or tool, you are separating the community into people that can throw out money every day and the ones that can't.
I probably see it this way because I come from the modding community around the Bethesda games, where it is forbidden to paywall mods.
In the end, I agree with you that People that put in a lot of work into great modifications deserve to get payed. But they should ask, not force the users to pay.
Star Trek did have money, within the federation there were transport credits and outside the were valuable materials usually exotic ores or metals.
There was also private property which seems to take some people by surprise.
I agree overall. Modders can and should be compensated for their work if they want. But I would personally much prefer if they offer it for free and allow for donations. That's a much better way to build a community. Especially since they are building sometimes small modifications on games they had no part in creating. And I especially am not a fan when they require you to subscribe to a patreon, with the idea essentially being that it could become a subscription.
I also checked out the mod patreon page. The author kinda sucks. People are voicing their frustration that he essentially added drm to a mod and his response is either that he doesn't care or...
So you didn't read. The authentication doesn't affect subscribers, if you have ever subscribed you can always pass the authentication. Only the people who want to pirate it should get pissed
Uhhh that's still drm.
Fuck Rockstar. They took my money and I'm still unable to play RDR2.