There's 100 other options that are more practical but 100% less cool
this post was submitted on 04 Oct 2023
274 points (91.3% liked)
Technology
59583 readers
3626 users here now
This is a most excellent place for technology news and articles.
Our Rules
- Follow the lemmy.world rules.
- Only tech related content.
- Be excellent to each another!
- Mod approved content bots can post up to 10 articles per day.
- Threads asking for personal tech support may be deleted.
- Politics threads may be removed.
- No memes allowed as posts, OK to post as comments.
- Only approved bots from the list below, to ask if your bot can be added please contact us.
- Check for duplicates before posting, duplicates may be removed
Approved Bots
founded 1 year ago
MODERATORS
Weird. I didn't know Gundams had wheels.
Fucking trash article. Every single outlet reporting on this is calling it a Gundam. Clearly we wouldn't know what a 15 foot tall robot is without someone comparing it to a 100ft bipedal machine with massive guns and lightsabers that looks totally different than what they're describing.
There are plenty of instances in anime where mechs (I guess not specifically Gundam) have wheels or skates/wheels, like Code Geass. I think its mostly so they don't have to animate walking on the ground or draw different leg movements/positions.
Edit: added stuff about drawing.
gundum suits arent real dude its fiction
thats just a lot of car parts assembled incorrectly
and a CEO
and maybe 1 or 2 enginees maybe
/ssssssss
yea when i saw the wheels i knew
this is a attempt at geting funding
that will not be spent on much more than the board members
Maybe...
Maybe...
Maybe I will live to see the legendary Mecha Duck Space Battles
STEP OFF
"Japan, we don't need to design a mecha for everything."
"But Gundam P1ANT will make crop harvesting 10% more efficient!"
"We need to get you into a war just so you have an outlet."
No, it's not for space exploration, and no, it wasn't unveiled by the nation of Japan. Hyperbole to the extreme, shame on you, Independent.
Some Japanese bloke built it after learning how to weld, and said he thinks it'd be cool if something like it could be used for space exploration one day.
There's no story here, just a guy doing simple DIY metalwork robotics.
The demands of space exploration weight reduction, weight reduction, compactness and weight reduction. The demands of disaster relief are probably all terrain mobility, strength and stability. Those attributes are polar opposites.
But the demand for mech suits is always very high.
Every time someone gets all self righteous and posts stuff about how this isn’t “practical” or “cost-effective” or “actually useful in a real world scenario, where efficacy is needed”.
They always forget the critical important factor: Mech Suits are Awesome!
hopes the robot could one day be used for disaster relief or in the space industry
Imagine I'd just fiddle around and build a few neat things and then hope they are going to be useful in outer space 😄
These guys 100% have no use case whatsoever for the thing they're building besides "dude let's MECHA"
I can respect that tbh, but pretending and dancing around it is a bit lame
"Disaster relief". One day someone will find this in some abandoned underground research facility on the Moon and realize it's the key to restoring peace on Earth.
GUNDUM
"space exploration"
So 1/4 scale mobile suit. Not quite a Gundam, but it's a start.
Get away from her you bitch!
Didn't Captain Disillusion already debunk this...?
Different co in SK.
If you sit in a seat, it's not a suit.
Gundam series mobile suits all were piloted from a seated position.
G gundam had these bodysuit they wore in a pod thing. Even a horse could pilot one.
Gundams aren't suits either.
And the ones in aliens were but they didn't call them that. Being a bit pedantic aren't you.
The Aliens power lifters are on the border of "Suit". You stand in them. The arms and legs have your arms and legs inside them, and they move as yours do. So yah I'd call that a suit that you wear. Just barely.
"Leg scooter" didn't test well with consumers 😹
boondoggle noun
- a wasteful and worthless project undertaken for political, corporate, or personal gain
I don’t know that I’d call this wasteful or worthless. Does it have a current application? Likely not. But that doesn’t mean it can’t be built upon.
Yeah it is wasteful or worthless. The designer even said "we made it to look like anime". Mechs are incredibly impractical in anything in the real world. There's a reason why they haven't been made (and that reason isn't "lack of technology")
The only reason we don't have mechanized suits fighting in a titanium octagon is the cost vastly outweighs the potential income.
It's entirely possible, entirely impractical, and while it looks super fucking cool to have a small mech suit you can walk around in, the cost will make any damages prohibitively expensive.
So basically right now it's nothing more than a toy, and ultimately it's not really trying to be. It's not a demo, and "proof of concept" is even pushing it. Like you said, the designers said basically the same thing.
It's basically telling a WWE fan that the whole thing isn't real and the wrestlers drama stories aren't true. They know. They don't care. It's entertainment for entertainments' sake.
We know it's not practical.. But come on.... points gundam suit.
The designers aren't also saying "this will be used to make mechs fight". They want it in disaster recovery and aerospace use. Where they are extremely not worth it.
I live on the same planet as someone who doesn't see the value of piloting this thing and shouting "get away from her you BITCH" or standing in awe of it and saying "Metal Gear?!"
This is a hobby for a man-child with more money and time than sense. I bet you the speed that the arms move in the video is the max they're capable of.
This will never be useful for any actual work. Someone might eventually buy it for a publicity stunt.
Disaster relief, huh? Sounds like you've got a job , 621...
I for one, wish to welcome our new mech-overlords who cannot climb stairs.
It's happening? IT'S HAPPENING GUYS!
Evangelion when?
Do you see any kaijus?
Not Yet but im Shure i can Summon some if necessary...
Every day and wondering when someone will do something about them. They are ruining my lawn.
Well Fukushima just dumped their waste last month...
When we figure out how to genetically engineer robots to not be robots but be aliens that are also robots that also are your dead mom.
All it's missing is the queen alien!