How i feel on Lemmy (programming.dev)
submitted 7 months ago by [email protected] to c/[email protected]
top 50 comments
sorted by: hot top controversial new old
[-] [email protected] 271 points 7 months ago

There were no actual efforts to establish communism in eastern europe. Only autocratic regimes backed by soviet russia.

[-] [email protected] 260 points 7 months ago

It's like saying democracy sucks because look at states like Democratic People's Republic of Korea, Democratic Republic of Congo and German Democratic Republic.

When people proclaim to be something doesn't make it true.

[-] [email protected] 41 points 7 months ago

I'm no too learned in the subject but what would "true" communism even look like on the large scale like a country? Would it even be feasible?

[-] [email protected] 113 points 7 months ago

True communism in a country is impossible.

You can have socialism, or anarchy, which we've seen before, but communism cannot function in one country alone, unless said country is completely and absolutely self reliant.

A major part of communism is internationalism, which is why socialist countries had the Comintern. (Communist International). Besides a political/social system, communism has a strong basis as an economic system. You can't apply communist economic system principles to the capitalist market.

To my knowledge, no existing country is self reliant to the point that they can completely cut off trade with the rest of the world. USSR didn't do it, China didn't do it and they were the two biggest countries at the time.

That, of course is all a very surface level ELI5, and if you want to ask something more specific or in depth, feel free to.

[-] [email protected] 33 points 7 months ago

Unless you’re an ultra-orthodox marxist, there is no such thing as trüe communism™.

There always have been many different ideas what „communism“ is, e.g. there have been various „nationalist communist“ ideologies (complicated by the fact that the Russian SFSR called everything „nationalist“ that wasn’t 100% aligned with its ideas of the Soviet Union, e.g. Hungary).

There are also no clear boundaries between communism, socialism, and anarchism, e.g. Kropotkin with his theories of anarchist communism.

That being said, I don’t think communism is a system (either social or economic), it’s strictly an idealogy, meaning it’s a way to achieve something, i.e. the classless and stateless society. If you follow that thought to its logical end, you cannot even „achieve“ communism at all, since at this point e.g. the proletariat ceases to exist, and as a result you cannot have a „dictatorship of the proletariat“.

It’s… complicated.

load more comments (13 replies)
load more comments (7 replies)
load more comments (2 replies)
load more comments (64 replies)
[-] [email protected] 206 points 7 months ago

The US political spectrum is leaning so far to the right. A US left is a France center or moderate right. So what Americans consider communism is merely what French consider moderate leftist.

  • I’m French living in the US
[-] [email protected] 85 points 7 months ago

Yeah, it's basically "If you keep calling all of the stuff I like 'communism', then I guess that makes me a communist."

load more comments (1 replies)
load more comments (6 replies)
[-] [email protected] 153 points 7 months ago

McCarthy propaganda go brrrr

[-] [email protected] 29 points 7 months ago

Also a terrible person. The world's big enough for there to be many terrible people in it. You need to create a very robust bureaucracy to keep corruption out and maintaining one is a very unglamorous job. Revolutionaries rarely have that skill set.

load more comments (1 replies)
[-] [email protected] 126 points 7 months ago

Well we're not praising fascism and corruption.

[-] [email protected] 31 points 7 months ago

The main issue is that they communism is economic policy, NOT social policy. While they do go hand in hand people often conflate the two. Many dictatorships use communism as a way to control the people but that doesn't mean that communism leads directly to dictatorships.

load more comments (22 replies)
load more comments (17 replies)
[-] [email protected] 99 points 7 months ago

More like: People on the internet being critical of the current system, Americans on the internet saying "COMMUNISM BAD" as if USSR style state capitalism is the only other possible option.

load more comments (17 replies)
[-] [email protected] 90 points 7 months ago* (last edited 7 months ago)

Didn't the USSR just do state capitalism, and not actual communism or socialism? And weren't they also totalitarian & also not a democracy? Are people actually asking for what was happening in astern Europe or something else?

[-] [email protected] 33 points 7 months ago

Yup. Also shot the anarchists, that worked with them and wanted democracy, in the back of the head during a meeting, The USSR then also did imperialism in their neighboring countries, deported a ton of people from those countries to death camps in siberia and allied with the nazies dividing Europe in their treaty

load more comments (2 replies)
load more comments (43 replies)
[-] [email protected] 87 points 7 months ago
[-] [email protected] 82 points 7 months ago

Communism isn't the issue the same way Capitalism isn't the issue, the issue is rich people abusing working class and poor people. Removing democracy from these systems just make them absolutely horrid in the long run. Also China isn't communist it's state capitalist dictatorship.

load more comments (6 replies)
[-] [email protected] 79 points 7 months ago

Fuck Communism and fuck unchecked capitalism. People deserve basic human rights. Free heallthcare, education, insurance and liveable basic income is a must. It doesn't make your society full of freeloaders instead it gives all the people a chance to become what they want in the society. I hope that people can see this basic difference and we can work towards for a better future as humanity instead of whatever country title.

[-] [email protected] 77 points 7 months ago

Fuck Communism and fuck unchecked capitalism

Interesting how capitalism needs the qualifier 'unchecked' while apparently communism has only one possible form.

load more comments (1 replies)
[-] [email protected] 63 points 7 months ago* (last edited 7 months ago)

The very concept of a free loader best represents the ruling class of capitalists interests. The ruling class does not contribute in any way to society, and instead steal billions of dollars of labor value from the working class and use it in ways that benefit only themselves. Allowing people to survive even without providing a capital benefit to the ruling class wouldn't enable free loading, it would mean society actually does what its supposed to and looks out for the wellbeing of all people.

You shouldn't have to work to exist. You shouldn't have to be useful to anyone else to be a part of a community. Food and shelter are human rights. Water is a human right. Healthcare and education are human rights.

Toppling capitalism and wage slavery is the only way to a just world. Socialism doesn't inherently belong to the soviet union. And the soviet union did not categorically fail at every single thing they did. Don't mistake my words for endorsement of stalinism or of any of the many horrible things they did. But there were other aspects of their society and governance that were actually pretty great. Its not all black and all white. Life isn't that simple in reality. A flat condemnation of communism is rooted in propaganda more than it is in reality.

And I'm an anarchist, before you accuse me of being a tankie. I do not advocate state communism. But to say "fuck communism" and be done with it just shows your bias towards socialism.

load more comments (23 replies)
load more comments (17 replies)
[-] [email protected] 69 points 7 months ago* (last edited 7 months ago)

7 out of 11 countries believe the end of the USSR harmed their countries rather than benefited them

Reflecting back on the breakup of the Soviet Union that happened 22 years ago next week, residents in seven out of 11 countries that were part of the union are more likely to believe its collapse harmed their countries than benefited them. Only Azerbaijanis, Kazakhstanis, and Turkmens are more likely to see benefit than harm from the breakup. Georgians are divided.

Hungary: 72% of Hungarians say they are worse off today economically than under communism

A remarkable 72% of Hungarians say that most people in their country are actually worse off today economically than they were under communism. Only 8% say most people in Hungary are better off, and 16% say things are about the same. In no other Central or Eastern European country surveyed did so many believe that economic life is worse now than during the communist era. This is the result of almost universal displeasure with the economy. Fully 94% describe the country's economy as bad, the highest level of economic discontent in the hard hit region of Central and Eastern Europe. Just 46% of Hungarians approve of their country's switch from a state-controlled economy to a market economy; 42% disapprove of the move away from communism. The public is even more negative toward Hungary's integration into Europe; 71% say their country has been weakened by the process.

Romania: 63% of the survey participants said their life was better during communism

The most incredible result was registered in a July 2010 IRES (Romanian Institute for Evaluation and Strategy) poll, according to which 41% of the respondents would have voted for Ceausescu, had he run for the position of president. And 63% of the survey participants said their life was better during communism, while only 23% attested that their life was worse then. Some 68% declared that communism was a good idea, just one that had been poorly applied.

Germany: more than half of former eastern Germans defend the GDR

Glorification of the German Democratic Republic is on the rise two decades after the Berlin Wall fell. Young people and the better off are among those rebuffing criticism of East Germany as an "illegitimate state." In a new poll, more than half of former eastern Germans defend the GDR.

28 percent of Czechs say they were better off under the Communist regime

Roughly 28 percent of Czechs say they were better off under the Communist regime, according to a poll conducted by the polling institute SC&C and released Sunday.

81% of Serbians believe they lived best in Yugoslavia

A poll shows that as many as 81 per cent of Serbians believe they lived best in the former Yugoslavia -”during the time of socialism”.

Majority of Russians

The majority of Russians polled in a 2016 study said they would prefer living under the old Soviet Union and would like to see the socialist system and the Soviet state restored.

The above memes are almost always made by Americans, whose brains are riddled with red scare brainworms and are completely devoid of any knowledge or understand of what the left thinks in Europe because Americans do not have a left.

load more comments (42 replies)
[-] [email protected] 62 points 7 months ago

I think the way we argue over labels hurts us. If I use heavy regulation and government aid to limit the abuses in a capitalist system, at what point does the label change to "socialism"? I think we do ourselves a disservice to create these strict conceptions of systems like capitalism, socialism, or communism. Then when one fails we get to say "well that wasn't true x". And the labels allow people to boogeyman an idea. And worst of all, we eliminate the possibility to take good lessons from multiple different systems and incorporate them into our system. I think we would be better served promoting policies on a case by case basis instead of using these huge words. And to be clear, I'm a bit of a hypocrite here. I've been mostly telling people I'm a "social democrat" or that I support "capitalism with heavy regulations". But even those words can get picked apart and don't really capture nuance. My main point is that I think this thread is a perfect encapsulation of how these arguments stop us from getting behind good policies when we bicker about the definitions of words that mean different things to different people.

load more comments (21 replies)
[-] [email protected] 62 points 7 months ago

A meme like this is what happens when you believe the GOP that doing anything to benefit regular people is communism.

load more comments (3 replies)
[-] [email protected] 61 points 7 months ago

Because the single only way to do communism is how the UdSSR did it, there's no other way.

And of course it's only possible to either agree with the whole of a specific ideology, or none of it. There's no "good parts of communism" or "bad parts of capitalism" it's only ever all good or all bad.

Politics is the mind-killer.

[-] [email protected] 60 points 7 months ago

western teenagers praising capitalism

the children sewing their clothes, harvesting their food, mining their metals, ...

load more comments (6 replies)
[-] [email protected] 60 points 7 months ago

What does "praising" mean? Being critical of what we learned in school about the USSR?

What does "communism" mean here? Advocating for the type of social democracy that's done pretty well in much of Europe?

I mean I know tankies "exist" but I rarely see them. Just because we're all critical of capitalism doesn't mean we're all dumb enough to want to re try what the soviet union did. It's almost like our kids will die under capitalism so we're willing to think outside the box for once.

load more comments (7 replies)
[-] [email protected] 56 points 7 months ago

How dare teenagers not become Neoliberals while growing up in a late capitalist hellscape where climate change can't be taken seriously because it isn't a profitable problem to solve.

load more comments (4 replies)
[-] [email protected] 55 points 7 months ago
load more comments (31 replies)
[-] [email protected] 54 points 7 months ago

I really find all these posts entertaining, there are a bunch of reddit refugees that are trying to impose their ideology on Lemmy. It's almost like they're trying to ironically colonize the space.

load more comments (6 replies)
[-] [email protected] 51 points 7 months ago

comment section frustratingly filled with McCarthy-brained liberals who have never critically examined their preconceptions about communism

load more comments (19 replies)
[-] [email protected] 49 points 7 months ago* (last edited 7 months ago)

A lot of eastern Europeans actually miss/look back fondly on the USSR days.... I'm not exactly a fan of them or other "communist" regimes, as they were all basically thinly veiled dictatorships, but standard of living was higher for most of the former block countries.

I really don't get all the china dick riding going on. I gotta think it's driven by bots and Chinese netizens. The west is a little unfair on their views of China, but they grab descenters with secret police and quash any form of opposition to their one party system. People who praise them and act like that's a better system are crazy. Really wish we could build some decent highspeed rail network in America though...

[-] [email protected] 38 points 7 months ago

I'm from an ex soviet country and I can tell you that the people who miss it are the ones who got free apartments and property from people who were kidnapped and sent to the soviet death camps in siberia. I have not met anyone else who misses that time when you had to live in constant fear being deported and worked to death and when your culture and language was basically criminalised.

load more comments (13 replies)
[-] [email protected] 37 points 7 months ago

I really don't get China being seen as a communist state. At this point it's a straight up fascist dictatorship.

load more comments (4 replies)
load more comments (4 replies)
[-] [email protected] 48 points 7 months ago

Idk if I speak for other people here but being critical of capitalism doesn't necessarily mean you want to copy paste North Korea. Or the Ukrainian SSR.

load more comments (8 replies)
[-] [email protected] 44 points 7 months ago

I wish we could look at what the ussr did right and how it worked around its restrictions without rose tinted glasses. Some central planning of efficient railways and large industrial machinery might not be a bad idea. Lezz a fair doesn't always produce great results. Walkable neighborhoods and commie blocks aren't such a bad idea but fascist dictators are.

load more comments (36 replies)
[-] [email protected] 44 points 7 months ago

boomers destroyed the earth beyond all belief, poisoned everyone with sketchy ass chemicals, destroyed the economy more than once (twice in my life), most of us will NEVER own a home because the housed your grand pappy paid 100k for is now worth 2.5 million and average yearly wage is less than 30,000... among a million other things. The greed and entitlement is baffling, mix that in with delusional red scare propaganda that a ton of people fall for and yall mfers spending time defending all this insane shit.

we effectively live in a corporate government where what the people want doesn't matter alongside the million other ways we are lied to and exploited. Billionaires and trillionaires run the world and they keep pushing for "the next thing" like the metaverse, blockchain and going mars while most of us cant even afford to fucking eat. Suck it. I guarantee that you cant even define communism and point out how it differs from social policies even on a very basic fundamental level. Fuck dude

load more comments (5 replies)
[-] [email protected] 34 points 7 months ago

Meanwhile in the real world

load more comments (5 replies)
[-] [email protected] 34 points 7 months ago
  • Universal access to healthcare, food, water, shelter, electricity, and education without cost.
  • Prohibit the operation of businesses or investments in basic necessities mentioned in previous point.
  • Non-essential amenities such as entertainment, fashion, travel, luxury goods etc continue to be available for purchase.
  • A reasonable tax structure that ensures higher taxes for the rich.

Is that Communism? Is that too much to ask for?

[-] [email protected] 29 points 7 months ago

Its more of a social democracy but no it is not too much to ask for. It should be the baseline

load more comments (8 replies)
[-] [email protected] 32 points 7 months ago

Stop at socialism. You never go full daddy-state.

load more comments (2 replies)
[-] [email protected] 31 points 7 months ago* (last edited 7 months ago)

Top: Filthy rich capitalists and Boomers that lick up their cool aid

Bottom: Global South that produces both their wealth

Blocking you I don't want another reddit experience

[-] [email protected] 31 points 7 months ago

Does it matter?

In America nothing means anything anymore. It's just soggy cardboard deteriorating. It can't be fixed. It's dead and not coming back. This is life now.

load more comments (5 replies)
[-] [email protected] 31 points 7 months ago

Oh yes because those same westerners are talking about Soviet Union 2, not democracy in the workplace.

load more comments (4 replies)
[-] [email protected] 30 points 7 months ago

communism is when ussr

load more comments
view more: next ›
this post was submitted on 22 Jul 2023
1473 points (79.2% liked)


42240 readers
3760 users here now


  1. Be civil and nice.
  2. Try not to excessively repost, as a rule of thumb, wait at least 2 months to do it if you have to.

founded 4 years ago