this post was submitted on 09 Feb 2024
16 points (100.0% liked)

Melbourne Trains

256 readers
8 users here now

About

c/MelbourneTrains is a community dedicated to all forms of public transport within the state of Victoria, Australia. We are a friendly and helpful community that welcomes anybody with an interest in Victoria public transport.

Rules

This community operates under the rules of aussie.zone. These apply to you regardless of which instance you are interacting from.

Credits

Community icon by @[email protected] featuring a W8 Class tram taken on April 17, 2022. Community banner by @[email protected] in the style of former Metropolitan PTV Platform sign. (aussie.zone icon in the community banner cleaned up by @[email protected].)

founded 1 year ago
MODERATORS
 
you are viewing a single comment's thread
view the rest of the comments
[–] [email protected] 2 points 9 months ago (1 children)

Personally I'm not a huge fan of them in their current use case, however I think little diesel rail cars like it would be very useful as shuttle services in places who've lost their passenger service due to lack of patronage, or just don't have a very good one.

There's a few ideas that come to mind as better use cases them going to and from Seymour all day:

  • They could run shuttles between Ballarat-Geelong

-They could run shuttles on the outer edges of the network which currently have quite poor service (Ballarat-Maryborough, Traralgon-Bairnsdale, Bendigo-Echuca, etc)

  • Some could be gauge converted and run Ararat-Horsham shuttles, or Ararat-Portland

I really think single DRCs still have a place in 2024. Vlocities can be nice, but 3 car set shuttles do seem a bit overkill for some of the above services. I don't think there's many people who'd rather have no service/a crappy coach over a single car sprinter shuttle to the nearest station

[–] [email protected] 2 points 9 months ago (1 children)

I think the biggest cost is the driver, and that doesn't change however long the train is, so it's probably not that more expensive to run vlocs

i really like how they look though

[–] [email protected] 1 points 9 months ago* (last edited 9 months ago) (1 children)

I had a look through the 2022-23 annual report and if I'm interpreting it right (high chance I'm not), the highest relevant costs are indeed staffing, but that's followed quite closely by vehicle maintenance / repairs. There's obviously not much that can be done about staff costs, but smaller trains = less maintenance, less surface area than can be graffitied/vandalised, etc. Vlines fuel costs aren't as high as I was expecting, although if a new generation of sprinters was ordered I imagine they'd have more efficient engines and be at about the same fuel efficiency as vlocities (my assumption is they'd do worse at the moment due to having an engine for every car and being older)

But really anything is doable if the political will is there

(Edit: this entire comment is just an assumption, to be clear. I don't think there's any more specific info out there, so the only thing I could think of was seeing whether or not fleet costs outweigh staffing costs annually or not, and they currently don't, but some staff included in the annual costs wouldn't be relevant to a shuttle service so that'd being the actual cost down a bit too. My final assumption is that staff costs and fleet costs work out about the same annually)

[–] [email protected] 1 points 9 months ago

I guess you could count a single sprinter unit as like a slightly better bus.

It'd be neat if you could take these trains around regional Victoria orbitally