this post was submitted on 25 Jul 2024
824 points (98.5% liked)
Lord of the memes
8062 readers
945 users here now
The Lord of the rings memes communitiy on Lemmy. Share memes about Lord of the rings and be respectful.
founded 1 year ago
MODERATORS
you are viewing a single comment's thread
view the rest of the comments
view the rest of the comments
How to differentiate from those who've read the book and those who haven't.
I assume OP just did their best to make up an example. She doesn't say anywhere that she is a superfan herself or even has read the books at all.
I assume it was made up because people do that
What's the catch? I've read the anthology a couple of times, albeit not in English, and I seem to miss the joke here.
The speech in the OP is Théoden's speech from the movie. In the book, he says,
and just a page or two later
(ROTK book 5, chapters 5 & 6)
Now, Eomer does say something very similar to Theoden's speech from the Charge of the Rohirrim, upon discovering his sister and assuming her dead:
and in the next paragraph
(later in ROTK book 5, chapter 6)
The line "Forth Eorlingas!" is Theoden's (though the Rohirrim also say it en masse), but it's from the chapter about Helm's Deep and the one preceding it. (TTT book 3, chapters 6 & 7).
And, look, Theoden's speech before the Charge of the Rohirrim at Pelennor is a cinematic masterpiece. And Bernard Hill (RIP) is probably the biggest reason why; his delivery is unimpeachable. In a lot of ways, the speech in the movie is better than what's in the books at that moment; but honestly they are trying to do different things.
So technically, the movie version is a bit heightened from the book version, and cobbled together from a few different sources. To put it all together:
Verbatim from Theoden's speech in ROTK chapter 5. Correctly placed in the narrative.
Also from Theoden's speech in ROTK chapter 5, but not quite verbatim (they added a "shall" in there, presumably for flow...or maybe just Bernard Hill forgot the exact line). Correctly placed in the narrative, though they left out "Fell deeds awake: fire and slaughter!" before this line.
Verbatim from Theoden's speech in ROTK chapter 5. Correctly placed in the narrative.
Also from Theoden's speech in ROTK chapter 5, with an extra "Ride!" thrown in. Correctly placed in the narrative.
Transplanted from Eomer's speech in ROTK chapter 6, with "to" replaced with "for," the order of the lines reversed, and the mood changed from despair to defiance.
Right character, wrong moment. Transplanted from Theoden's speech in TTT chapter 7 at Helm's Deep, but in the same vein as Theoden's shout of "Up Eorlingas!" from the beginning of ROTK chapter 6.
So Kelly, from the original tweet, probably overheard her husband reading Chapter 5 of ROTK, and her brain filled in the movie version of the quote while she was writing the tweet.
I'm delighted to see a lore scholar come and help me out. Thank you. I hope I'd be as helpful to some anon as you were to me.
You honor me, friend. Far more than I deserve.
You may go now to your fathers, and even in their mighty company, you shall not now be ashamed
This is something I miss from reddit, thank you.
Happy to help.
Had to check that you username wasn't Den of Geek <3 Fascinating, thank you!
I'm just a guy with a digital version of the book easy at hand. You're welcome!
Everyone, I've found Stephen Colberts Lemmy account! . . . .
.
.
Neeeeeeeerd!!!
Would that I were so lucky.