EDIT: I was wrong. I must have come across the site way back when it was a plain white page with black text. https://bfro.net/avevid/mjm/deerkills.asp

Can someone please help with find this ancient site, maybe on archive.org?

Something like fifteen years ago there was a site, almost all text, that discussed whether or not Sasquatch people hunted deer, specifically in Ohio. It included a good number of accounts where people had found things like a small cave with neatly stacked deer legs, carcasses with missing livers, and so on.

Many people are aware of these stories in general now, but this site was one of the few that was chock full of detailed personal accounts.

I don't think it was early BFRO or BigfootEncounters.