62
Dump Plex, they already a lot less free than should be tolerated by self hosters.
this post was submitted on 18 Sep 2023
62 points (95.6% liked)
Plex
2496 readers
1 users here now
Welcome to Plex, a community dedicated to Plex, the media server/client solution for enjoying your media!
founded 1 year ago
MODERATORS
Yeah, Jellyfin is really great. I’m sure there are things that Plex does better, but Jellyfin does everything I’ve asked it to.
Intro skipping? Offline playback? I'd love to ditch Plex, but I use these features regularly.
My favourite Jellyfin feature is the one where it doesn't 'accidentally' reset my dashboard every few weeks to promote its garbage free streaming partners. I don't think I could give that feature up.
Yes you can use a plug-in for intro skipping, and can download for offline playback.
And opposed to current plex not just the person paying premium can directly download from the web ui, but everyone who has permissions.
Individual episodes without transcoding however.
I’d like intro skipping. But none of these features are enough for me to switch from jellyfin. Luckily, sending the files to vlc is easy enough for offline playback.
There's always this plugin. Its a little annoying to get the skip button working but you can just set it to make a chapter marker so you can skip with that. Though be warned it will hog resources until its done scanning everything on the first run
When Jellyfin has Plexamp, I might consider it
https://github.com/jmshrv/finamp
I'm not sure how they compare as I am not a music person, but there are a few apps that function as a Jellyfin music player.
Thanks for the link. I'll check it out.
I actually had to look it up because it sounded like Winamp, but it didn't kick llama's ass. Is that what they kept peddling along with Tidal sub?
Honest question, do you not have Prime or Apple music sub or stuff you listen to is so unique, neither of those have it?
By far the best music player I have ever used. My music library is 24K tracks, so I have no need of any music service and use plexamp exclusively.
That sounds like a massive enough collection to never get bored with, but don't you want new music at least on occasion? Do you just buy individual songs or albums and add to your collection? Do costs add up? I imagine redundant storage with at least some sort of backup for collection that large isn't cheap.
Just trying to compare it to streaming service I get as part of my $120/year Prime membership.
I probably average a couple of albums a month (I only buy albums unless something is not available as part of an album). My storage is a Synology 920+ with 36Tb it's just over half full. I hear new music all the time. (But have you listened to new music?). I'm going to see Greta Van Fleet on Friday (I guess that might be considered new'ish) if there's an opening act, and they're any good, I'll buy some of their music.
Sure put I paid for it more then a decade ago. And Jellyfin still has some bugs that are annoying.
In recent years, copyright holders have repeatedly requested Plex to take more action against piracy.
Their preferred method of logging into your own home server by going through their website should really give you pause when reading about how anti-piracy organizations pressure them.
Anonymous Data
In addition to the information described above, Plex collects anonymised data when users interact with our services. This includes:
- Server / library data
- DVR device information: manufacturer name and model
There have been numerous stories over the years about how anonymized data isn't really anonymous.
There was a thread on [email protected] a few days ago with pic of the notice people are receiving.
https://kbin.social/m/[email protected]/t/457315/Plex-to-block-all-servers-hosted-at-Hetzner
Surely Plex can come up with a way to accurately identify those that are actually running dodgy paid servers against the TOS and leave the smaller guys alone.
I know the whole idea of the shared library is already pushing laws to the limit but those that are running large scale paid servers will eventaully ruin it for everyone.
It's always the case of a small group ruining the whole thing for everyone. Identifying and removing big dodgy paid servers would be a good middle ground without punishing the others.
Let's be honest, what Plex offers was too good to be true, and too good to last
Wasn’t it Plex that led to LastPass getting breached?
I mean, why isn’t everyone using open source at this point? Companies are just clamming to suck up as much money as possible from people still stupid enough not to learn from what every other company has done! 🤦♂️
Lifetime passes vs monthly subs. FOSS equivalent product don't exist considering live TV guide, default SSL security, integration with settop media boxes, etc that Plex offers... jellyfin is close but far from the decades of polish and half baked features Plex have added
It was a very old, unpatched Plex server running on hardware that had access to LastPass critical data.
If you ran very old FOSS with unpatched vulnerabilities, you'd have the same problem. It wasn't Plex that did it, it was unmaintained self-hosting.
Plex has it's problems, but this wasn't one of them.