The freedom of speech
this post was submitted on 29 Aug 2023
5 points (100.0% liked)
Legal Discussions Canada
72 readers
1 users here now
Related Communities
- Legal Advice Canada
- Legal Discussions Canada (here!)
- Best of Legal Advice Canada
For off-topic, hypothetical, or general discussions that are legal in nature.
founded 1 year ago
MODERATORS
Self defense.
You have a legal obligation to retreat at every opportunity. Self defense is only valid if you've exhausted every possible avenue of retreat.
This is to prevent the propagation of violence, and it's effective, and it's how self defense laws are in all civilized countries.
Where does the code state that? I'm having trouble finding a legal obligation for retreat.
It's half and half.
You aren't obligated to retreat, but every use of force needs to be justifiable at each point. You will be forced to prove you had no other option than force.
And if you look, you'll find Canada is very picky about that justification.
That’s not wrong, but I feel like people take those kinds of comments to either extreme and tend to skip right over the reasonable middle ground. The thing about force is there’s an expectation that one uses a reasonable level of force to suit the situation, in some cases this can mean use of lethal force, and in other cases this can mean simply removing oneself from the situation. There’s even been weird cases where one party was found to be justified in the use of force, and as the altercation progressed the second party was found to be justified in further use of force against the first party due to the first parties force being excessive for the situation.
The biggest difference between Canada’s self defence regulations and those present in some states is that some states allow certain situations like trespassing or break and enter to be considered enough of a threat to respond with lethal force. Canada’s laws usually require an articulation of an imminent threat.
"you have the right to remain silent" etc
We do actually have the right to remain silent in Canada. Police officers are not required to yell at you about it while they arrest you, though.
Refusing to provide ID/driver's license in a traffic stop.
Misdemeanours and felonies are US. The former is roughly equivalent to summary offences and felonies are roughly equivalent to indictable offences.
We also have hybrid offenses ("wobblers") which allows the Crown discretion in determining how they want to elect to proceed, meaning they can be pursued as either, depending on the facts of the case and other strategic concerns like whether they want to restrict the option for jury trial (only available for indictable at the discretion of the defendant)