Slightly off-topic but feel free to use our collaborative text editor for sharing and working on drafts: https://pads.slrpnk.net
this post was submitted on 16 Jun 2024
23 points (96.0% liked)
✍️ Writing
109 readers
1 users here now
A community for writers, like poems, fiction, non-fiction, short stories, long books, all those sorts of things, to discuss writing approaches and what's new in the writing world, and to help each other with writing.
Rules for now:
1. Try to be constructive and nice. When discussing approaches or giving feedback to excerpts, please try to be constructive and to maintain a positive vibe. For example, don't just vaguely say something is bad but try to list and explain downsides, and if you can, also find some upsides. However, this is not to say that you need to pretend you liked something or that you need to hide or embellish what you disliked.
2. Mention own work for purpose and not mainly for promo: Feel free to post asking for feedback on excerpts or worldbuilding advice, but please don't make posts purely for self promo like a released book. If you offer professional services like editing, this is not the community to openly advertise them either. (Mentioning your occupation on the side is okay.) Don't link your excerpts via your website when asking for advice, but e.g. Google Docs or similar is okay. Don't post entire manuscripts, focus on more manageable excerpts for people to give feedback on.
3. What happens in feedback or critique requests posts stays in these posts: Basically, if you encounter someone you gave feedback to on their work in their post, try not to quote and argue against them based on their concrete writing elsewhere in other discussions unless invited. (As an example, if they discuss why they generally enjoy outlining novels, don't quote their excerpts to them to try to prove why their outlining is bad for them as a singled out person.) This is so that people aren't afraid to post things for critique.
4. All writing approaches are valid. If someone prefers outlining over pantsing for example, it's okay to discuss up- and downsides but don't tell someone that their approach is somehow objectively worse. All approaches are on some level subjective anyway.
5. Solarpunk rules still apply. The general rules of solarpunk of course still apply.
founded 1 year ago
MODERATORS
Thank you, that's very much on-topic I'd say! I'm sure this will come in handy 👀
Will you be doing it here? I love stuff like this. I'm not in because I'm not a writer, but I used to be part of a songwriting club that operated like this. It really helped with both my craft and motivation and the feedback was amazing.
Good luck, and I hope this turns out amazing!
Thanks for the words of encouragement! That is indeed heartening to hear.
Yes for simplicity and visibility I thought here would be best. Maybe a side community if it starts to suck up too much of the oxygen in the room, but that's counting chicks before they hatch.
Oh an idea: we could make a writing club community where people can post about process and post stories to get feedback. Then there could be a pinned weekly/monthly post that has goals and other general discussion and well as letting people say if they want motivational DMs
I like this idea a lot. I was wondering about how to organise everything in one post, and it's probably a recipe for disaster after a certain size haha. A specialised community is a good solution for that.
I do want to see how things go here for a bit before getting too fancy, since this is a pretty quiet community, and also my motivation has a way of fleeing me as soon as Monday rolls around hehe, so I don't want to take on too much too quickly.
Makes sense, a new community probably wouldn't be necessary at the start & this community could probably use the extra traffic anyways :)
Maybe a way to organize it within the post is having topic specific comments? You could even link to the comments within the main body of the post.
For example you could have a comment that says: comment here for dm motivation. Then people can reply to that specific comment and it'll all be nested. Things might get tricky if the post gets too much activity, but I get the feeling it will probably be a small group :)
I like the idea of linking things back to the main post yeah. Very small scale, but probably adequate for our use, like you said :)
For DM motivation I'm just going to take the risk and assume that unless someone says otherwise that they will be ok with it.
I wasn't planning on really hectoring anyone: just a gentle reminder about a week before the "deadline" that there is at least one person (me) who will be genuinely curious about any progress (or no) that they've made towards their goal.
I think thats a great approach & your energy seems perfect for it, kind and motivating without feeling overbearing :)
Sounds like a great idea! There could be a monthly or quarterly post to encourage people to link (or quote, if not too long) the various things they want feedback on in the response comments.
I did in a previous writing community run into the issue that people would, when somebody discussed general writing approaches, point back to their own previous feedback posts and find flaws in the posts to try to "prove" to them their more general thoughts on writing approaches was wrong. Which in my opinion scares people away from daring to post their work, when it later comes back at them in a more general discussion.
Therefore, I would only request people stick with "3. What happens in feedback or critique requests posts stays in these posts" which I suggested as a rule for that reason.
Super good point! Also I don't know if you saw, but we've been doing the writing club in this community. I think there are 3 or 4 of us who have been consistently checking in, but we have had a few people chime in just for the month. I can link to it if you haven't already seen those posts.
So far it has luckily been a very positive and motivational space :) no one getting weird and nitpicky, mostly just encouraging eachother to keep up with writing
Almost a year ago I started trying to write solarpunk fiction and got daunted by the amount of research I needed. Writing scifi had always meant extrapolating current trends and pointing out problems. To do solarpunk I had to be able to offer solutions and that meant lots and lots of reading to learn from the folks who've been talking about and trying out alternative ways of doing things (from agriculture to infrastructure to anarchy) and thinking through their answers.
For awhile I did a worldbuilding art/essay project focusing on very small glimpses of a solarpunk future, trying to emphasize things like creative reuse, industry, and seasons/weather that didn't show up much in solarpunk visual art. The narrow focus helped a lot.
I think I'm finally comfortable trying to write something, though instead of a short story I'm working on a campaign for the solarpunk TTRPG Fully Automated, where the players are on a treasure hunt for tons of industrial waste which were illegally dumped sixty years before. The waste is valuable because it's a useful input in the production of geopolymers, and the stakes are high as the largely-abandoned rural town they're searching is in the process of being deconstructed and rewilded, so nobody else is likely to notice it in the future.
I've had a lot of fun building a wide swath of locations, communities, and means of travel for the players to possibly explore, along with the rough outline of the decades-old conspiracy and coverup murder.
My goal is to build out the characters, build out the past/conspiracy, and to start seeding people and locations in the present with clues for that mystery.
Oh cool! Truly, I can't wait to hear more about this. I'll add a link to your comment in the main post.
So my goal is to have a detailed (enough) map drawn up for the fictional land where my story takes place. Not the whole world, just the immediate area encompassing a midden situated in a mountain range, to a nearby outpost.
I recently finished reading A Wizard of Earthsea, and the map and the world inspired me to get back to this story I've been mulling around for over a year - and what better start than a map! :D
As a stretch goal, I would like to connect scenes between two characters: 1) A scavenger of info tech at the middens, to 2) a soldier to a diminishing empire being held captive at the nearby outpost.
I'm so dang interested it's crazy
Can I put you down for a monthly goal? ;)
Yes pls
-
I want to have finished my full cast , series outline and pilot script for my main project by August
-
I want to write at least a 2k word piece of fanfiction
-
I want to find a writing partner for an experimental project, to see what it's like collaborating in that way
Thanks for the deets, and wow so much! I can't wait to hear more about it. A script! That's so cool!!
My goal this month is to finish the scenes I've started for my book (I have 3 very rough drafts), and to do some more adjusting to my outline.
My less specific goal is to spend more time focused on one project, rather than jumping around to different stories every time I write.
Nice, that sounds very ambitious to me, but I'm also nowhere near even attempting a book haha. So do you envision getting your 3 rough drafts to a second draft, or even final draft stage?
Maybe I'm mixing up "scenes" and "drafts" here, though.
... spend more time focused on one project, rather than jumping around to different stories every time I write.
This is painfully relatable. I haven't tried it for writing, but for my day job, I've had some small luck with the Pomodoro method.
I'm excited to hear more about how both your goals go!
So when I write, I typically start by getting inspired about an over arching story. I make up an outline, then to fill it in I start with scenes that feel very important or that I can really visualize. I then write those, modify the outline if necessary and write more scenes as they come to me. The scenes often get revised as more and more of the story comes together & the scenes get joined into larger and larger fragments until a complete story is there. Sometimes scenes get radically changed or dropped as the process goes on.
Then when it feels done, I have a first draft that I edit as a cohesive piece & get feedback on.
So I'm still at the generating scenes and modifying the outline stage. Hopefully I'm not being too ambitious, but any progress will be progress :)
I've tried pomedoro method & it can be great for getting past that initial inertia & actually getting into the flow of writing. Thanks for all you kind words & good luck with your world building and map making this month :D
I have a couple writing projects I've been working on and would love a collaborative space to both motivate and inspire eachother :)
Do you think we would share our writing in addition to talking about the process? It could be opt in for people who aren't as comfortable sharing their actual writing.
I have a couple writing projects I've been working on and would love a collaborative space to both motivate and inspire eachother :)
Heck yeah, that's what I'm about.
Do you think we would share our writing in addition to talking about the process? It could be opt in for people who aren't as comfortable sharing their actual writing.
I would love to deep dive into someone else's writing and really nerd out on the details, but I bone-deep understand the trepidation of baring your work-in-progress writing to another person or people.
So yeah, encouraged, but not necessary IMHO. I'm fine going by the honour system if someone just wants to talk about what they're doing, but not ready or willing to show it.
What do you think?
That sounds great! Definetly isn't mandatory, just a nice option for people who want to be able to talk about nitpicky details and get specific feedback. Maybe if there are enough people we could do a voice chat or something.
I'm part of a discord based book club that has weekly voice chats & they're definetly a nice addition.
I might be getting too far ahead of myself with ideas though lol I'm just spitballing, I'm excited for anything you decide to do, glad you had this idea :)
Wow I'm also part of a weekly discord book club, what're the odds lol!
Personally I'd prefer to stay off corporate platforms if possible, but I don't by any means consider this "my" bookclub - I'm just hoping to get the ball rolling, because it's the kind of thing I wish existed around here hehe