Patient Gamers

I played this on the PS2 and it's s fantastic experience.

Interestingly, the PAL version (and probably the Japanese version, too) has content that wasn't in the NA version. There's an extra puzzle, a semi-hidden alternative "funny/happy" coda after the main ending if you play through a second time, and some extra in-game options that are unlocked after you finish the game for the first time, including understandable subtitles for ALL characters, even ones that are normally speaking an unknown language. I'm not sure if the hidden weapon you can get in the middle of the game becomes a light saber on the second playthrough in the NA version as it does in the PAL version, but it may.

This was before video streaming sites, so there were many arguments on forums about how these things are in the game, no they aren't you trolls, yes they are here's a picture, that's obviously fake... and so on. It was interesting that once people figured out that the NA and PAL versions were different, there was a vocal core of NA players still insisting that it was all fake for quite a long time afterward.

I would like to point out, if someone hates escort quests in games (like myself) this game is a hard pass.

Sometimes we say about some games “they don’t hold your hand”

However, there is a lot of hand holding in the game :)

I'd like to add an opposite take - not to disregard your opinion but to maybe tamper the expectations a little.

ICO is a game I really wanted to play for years. Besides being widely praised and held as a classic, it just looked interesting even though I didn't knew much about it (on purpose). All I knew was that a boy and a girl travel through some ruins and there's a button to hold hands - that's it.

After finishing it, all that comes to mind is: it was... fine?

I really like what the devs did (or at times tried to do). I liked the atmosphere, (limited) story and the general idea behind it all. Unfortunately, the good didn't manage to overcome the bad/mediocre parts for me.

Gameplay was mostly fine if not for the tedious combat which happens a lot. It was bad enough there were multiple times when I entered a room, saw enemies spawning in and thought to myself "I really don't want to deal with this right now" followed by a switch to Tetris DX. I made it through, but the combat in this game is absolutely not good enough to carry this amount of it.

It's not even a case of it being janky (I can deal with that), it just wasn't engaging in general (even though, again, I do understand what they were going for).

Levels were interesting in concept but I think they went a bit too far in trying to make them look like a "real place" without filling them with enough details - the final effect is large, empty maps that could be vastly improved, even on original hardware.

Music was kind of there. It's not bad but for some reason it was completely forgettable for me. The only track I could remember after finishing the game was the save point song (listening to it actually makes me smile, not sure if it's just due to the song itself or how I associate it with not having to fight anymore). I ended up listening to the OST on youtube and was constantly thinking "oh yeah, I did hear this song!" and definitely like what I heard, it's just that almost none of them really registered when I played.

It's been a few months since I finished the game so I think I mellowed out a bit on how I feel about it. Just so we're clear, I never outright disliked it. I'm glad I got to experience ICO and I did like what I played overall but I don't think I'll touch it ever again.

I'd love to try it, but I don't want to buy yet another console. If I could play it on Steam Deck, that would be ideal.