I haven't used any of them, and I doubt I will ever bother with centralised social media again. Some places I'll keep a presence on, but I won't ever meaningfully engage or invest with centralised stuff. The combination of lack of will to protect minorities and the ability to just lose everything at once, just isn't something I want to deal with anymore.
this post was submitted on 07 Aug 2023
30 points (96.9% liked)
Asklemmy
43963 readers
1293 users here now
A loosely moderated place to ask open-ended questions
If your post meets the following criteria, it's welcome here!
- Open-ended question
- Not offensive: at this point, we do not have the bandwidth to moderate overtly political discussions. Assume best intent and be excellent to each other.
- Not regarding using or support for Lemmy: context, see the list of support communities and tools for finding communities below
- Not ad nauseam inducing: please make sure it is a question that would be new to most members
- An actual topic of discussion
Looking for support?
Looking for a community?
- Lemmyverse: community search
- sub.rehab: maps old subreddits to fediverse options, marks official as such
- [email protected]: a community for finding communities
~Icon~ ~by~ ~@Double_[email protected]~
founded 5 years ago
MODERATORS
Yea ... this! It's the big picture here. The multiple platforms that are FOSS, with each of their instances being completely separate ... it's a non-trivial amount of freedom you can't get anywhere else, not to mention the potential for it (or its idea) to continue to grow and evolve.
I haven't spent much time with Tildes, but I noticed that they have least tried to address the problems with Reddit, rather than just be clone.
One example is putting the 'Add Comment' button at the very bottom of the screen, encouraging you to read existing comments before you make your own. Another is the use of labels, included 'noise' and 'malice', so that comments can be hidden from other users with a bit more nuance than a downvote, and 'exemplary' - which, if enough people use it - will promote a particularly insightful comment.
It does intrigue me, because I don't think the only issues with Reddit were ads and the actions of a pesky CEO.
Yes, I like tildes. Basically, it has less chance of misogynistic neckbeard.
I liked squabbles, but it has the same vulnerabilities as reddit or any other social networking site. Lemmy appealed to me because of it's decentralized, federated nature.
Centralized communities all turn into what Twitter and Reddit became eventually. They benefits for the owners (money, control) are too great to ignore forever once you’re big enough. Decentralized communities have more resilience, provided no individual server gets too big.
This is a problem that can arise with Lemmy. If everybody signs up to lemmy.world, it can become so big that everybody will sign up to that instance and they can break the federation at any time.
When i was in squabbles, it was flooded by people making self posts that were obnoxious and super cringe, where they mainly talked about how they are the first people there and part of greatness. Or some girls who needed so much attention that they made 5 posts an hour, that was heavily upvoted, because girls. It was basically a worse version of facebook
Every single week they have some stupid bullshit drama I just can't get interested in. Last week I logged in and posted saying something about how every single time I check the site there's drama, and one of the people who replied to me was exactly the kind of person you described trying to tell me that there's not that much drama.
I almost pulled a "this you" because less than an hour ago they'd posted that they were soooo depressed over the drama, but... not worth it. Also they posted five times that hour so you nailed the estimate exactly.
I'd say it's worse than Facebook at this point.
The first part is exactly what happened here.
Are they federated and open source?
Idk about raddle (don't even know what it is) but the others aren't.
Tildes is AGPL licensed Free Software. But yeah, the author has no plans to add federation support.
Oh yeah I was just responding to the federation part of the question
Raddle is not federated as far as I know. It seems to be using Postmill which uses the permissive zlib License.
Raddle and Tildes are open source
- Squabbl(es|r) : Personally found UI ugly , had bit obnoxious branding IMHO , apparently there was weird drama on there . As of writing this it got renamed Squabblr . Removing "e" from "(.*)er" ? sooooo 2007 ‼️
- Raddle : Not anarchist, so just not for me (am leftist but don't identify with it specificly)
- Tildes : Extremely basic UI, otherwise know nothing and don't care to
I am using tildes, and compared to lemmy it's community is small. But I love it because of this. Since community is small I feel like I really am a significant part of the community.
I'm jealous of the tildes app since I loved reddit is fun.
I'm partial to the fediverse, I don't want to be the product. I moved away from Google for that reason. And when it became obvious that Reddit was more akin to Google than say Wikipedia then my hand was forced.
Tildes is a hideously ugly walled-garden circlejerk from the little I've seen of it, Squabblr.co seems neat but is very low-population (and without the fedi crossover I'm not sure if it'll survive), and I've never even heard of Raddle before this.
No opinion. Because I never used them. I guess they would be boring because of lack of content and creative people
I enjoyed squabblr at first but the dev has already made terrible choices so I'm not into it. The community is good though, so that's a bummer. Raddle is insane. They are leftist fascists. I'm super left, but a bunch of teenagers pining for anarchy is absurd. Its so clear that most of them don't know what they are talking about in the slightest. I noped out of there quickly.
The “teenagers pining for anarchy” bit had me laughing. Teenagers may say they want anarchy, but they don’t want REAL anarchy. They’re just tired of adults telling them what to do. Teenagers aren’t stupid, either. They should know the difference, and I bet a lot of them do.
Considering how awful people can be, I don’t want real anarchy, either, but at least I’m not some edgelord who pretends he does. Squabblr doesn’t sound like a community I could stomach for long. Noping out probably saved your sanity.
What terrible choices, out of curiosity?
I joined Raddle because I wanted to keep up with r/traa, r/egg_irl, and r/ennnnbbbyyyy 😭😭😭😭
Tildes has a single admin who bans anyone they mildly disagree with.