I prefer Homebrew World, it's like Dungeon World 2.0 in many cases, but it's for sure tailored for oneshots or short campaigns. There are also DW: Unlimited Dungeons which shares some similarities with HbW, and Stonetop in its early access stage
this post was submitted on 07 Jul 2023
4 points (100.0% liked)
Dungeon World
435 readers
1 users here now
founded 2 years ago
MODERATORS
It's not the hot points that bother me, it's using all the different d&d dice (D20, d8, etc). I like that other pbta games just use 2d6
I understand that. All that dice juggling and optimazation, wasn’t that fun.
But unlike dnd, the dice is specific to each class. So a fighter will always use a d10. No matter if it is a sword, dagger, whip, etc.
And I really like how a fighter will generally be much more deadly than a wizard. Like in some hacks the dage is a d6 +/-X. And for me, it makes the damage between the classes feel very samy.
When you say variants, do you mean the house ruled ones or the ones who published theirnown thing, yet still try to dip into fantasy genre?
Like Homebrew World is house ruled version and Fantasy World is its own thing.
Chasing adventure was a 'house ruled' Dungeon World, but now is its own published thing.
What does Homebrew World change?
I am just looking for other peoples experience with 'House Ruled' variants and spin offs of it. I only have experience with MotW, and I find the hit points in Dungeon World kind of awkward.
https://spoutinglore.blogspot.com/2018/07/homebrew-world.html
upd: hit points in DW is like plot armor, it's not about health state explicitly
What makes HP feel different from Harm? It is essentially the same in my head. I also really like that in Dungeon World, that the game isn't bogged down by what weapon does the most damage. It is all in the characters capabilities.
I haven't looked at every hack of Dungeon World. But they all slightly changes some of the moves here and there. Either in ways I like or not.
Homebrew World has a slightly different take on inventory and the defend move I really enjoy. But it still uses spell lists. But it is more or less my go-to for one-shots due to it having much less mechanics.
I really liked Worlds of Adventure new stats (the unpublished version) and that race no longer has a hard mechanic behind it. But Wizards still use a spell list.
Unlimited Dungeons has a neat mechanic for wizard spells, but I find it still quite limiting an rigid. Its heritage mechanic is neat, but I do not like its "mark box to use ability"-aspect. But if the heritage aspect is removed, it is a nice hack.
My favorit is my own hack, Mixed Adventures, which combines the various aspects I enjoy from the hacks. The most unique part of it is how it handles spell casting which isn't a fixed list. The character chooses couple aspects for their magic (spheres/domain) that determine what they can do with their magic. The player simply describes a spell that fits. And if it seems like to much, the GM may add requirements or say it must be a ritual (ala Monster of the Week).
Yes! If I want some kind of mage/spellcaster in my game, I go for Unlimited Dungeons variant. Bot DW and HbW mage variants are disappointedly limited
If you want spellcasting to be even more freeform, Mixed Adventure follows more the logic of most other moves, were the player describes what the character does and their intention. Each "school/domain", doesn't have their own move. It just determines how the fiction can be shaped by the character.
Edit: Updated the link
You can create post here, dedicated to your hack. DW subreddit isn't accessible now, I've managed to reach your old post there via cached search page but it's kinda unrelialable :)
~~Can you share mage playbook?~~ Never mind, I've taken it from cached reddit page)))
Oh dear o_O ! I pasted in the wrong link.. Here is the right link (i hope). There is a folder with the individual playbooks as well.
I am also working on making a "Proper" file like with the other hacks, explaining some of the changes.
view more: next ›