Nolan is the one that mixes his more for top of the line cinema which means most viewers can barely hear dialog...
So I wonder if his Blu ray sound mix is going to be shit unless you have a crazy home theater set up
this post was submitted on 15 Nov 2023
244 points (95.5% liked)
Home Video (VHS, DVD, Blu-ray, 4k)
695 readers
1 users here now
On Reddit we have r/dvdcollection, r/boutiquebluray, r/4kbluray, r/steelbook, r/vhs, etc but let's start simply with a community to cover all the forms of home video collecting.
So, do you feel nostalgic for a format? Are you looking forward to a release? Heard any exciting news? Want to show us your shelves? Then post away.
Elsewhere on the Fediverse:
- [email protected]
- [email protected]
- [email protected]
- [email protected]
- [email protected]
- [email protected]
- [email protected]
- [email protected]
- [email protected]
- [email protected]
- [email protected]
Chat:
Rules:
- Be excellent to each other
founded 1 year ago
MODERATORS
Yep most likely. “Preserve the soundscape” for him just means it’s gonna sound bad on a typical tv speaker, soundbar, or 2.1 system that most people have at home. Maybe if you have a center channel, you’ll still have a chance to hear the dialogue without getting your ears blasted by the soundtrack or an explosion.
"Fuck the people who buy my movies without first buying 10k home theater setups"
-Christopher Nolan
A passible 5.1 system is like $550
That's the price of a passable subwoofer.
That's the last fuckin thing I would spend half a thousand on lmao
You sir are mistaken. How the fuck am I going to watch mostly cartoons with out my McIntosh ma12000 pushing all that sweet juice into my pair of GoldenEar Triton Ones?
Literally unwatchable
I hope the mix is better than Tenet. I haven't seen Oppenheimer yet, but I'll be picking up the 4K next week.
I've got a 5.1.2 system and with Tenet I could still barely hear wtf was going on.
Nolan is one of the reasons I have subtitles on everything.
Watching tenet at home was basically impossible lol the sound was a total shitshow
He also put really loud droning music under dialogue to make sure you can't understand what they are saying.
Christopher Nolan says buy ‘Oppenheimer’ on Blu-ray "because I get paid more from a Blu-ray sale than a stream view." /cynical
It can be both. :P He has a point about streaming services.
Although he likely makes as much or more from a digital purchase.
You reckon? I mean, you might be right but I'd be really surprised if the payout from a streaming service for one person watching Oppenheimer was even close to that from a Blu-Ray sale.
Streaming perhaps, I was talking about digital purchases. Streaming is worth buttons.
Ah, sorry, I misunderstood your point. You might well be right
Christopher "we don't provide mixes for substandard audio setups" Nolan puts a lot of effort into home releases?
If he's having trouble with getting the sound right for the home market, he should find a 'loudness' switch on any stereo system from the '80s. Does the trick.
I think a big part of the issue is that people don't have home stereos like they did in the 80s. It's hard to mix sound so that it sounds good on flatscreen TV speakers and $80 wal-mart sound bars.
I've got a pretty good sound bar with separate subwoofer. It's about as good an audio setup as any non-audiophile is likely to have. And you know what? Blockbuster movies still sound awful on it.
I love Interstellar to bits- it's one of my favourite films, and I've watched it at home several times. But the sound mix on it is just dire; dialogue that you can't hear over background wind-rustling-in-trees sound effects, crescendo music so loud that it wakes the neighbours, scenes which oscillate from whisper-quiet to shake-the-masonry and back again within minutes.
There's no excuse for that; it's just bad mixing.
Please don't be like Pans' Labyrinth and put the 7.1 audio on the Blu Ray and 4k is stuck with 5.1 track -.-
Christopher Nolan movies always have 5.1 audio, never 7.1.
It's not mastered in 7.1. Both versions seem to be 5.1 only.
Any idea when it will be released? It is a wonderful movie, although I seriously doubt my TV will be able to provide the room-shaking experience that we had in the cinema...
Any idea when it will be released?
22nd November 2023
Thanks!
You can do that with some DIY but it needs some tinkering and a touch of plutonium.
Wrong kind of shaking, bud
I doubt my wife will let me do that...
If you have a 5.1 system with a subwoofer, it gets pretty close. Unfortunately you cannot really crank it up that if you live in an apartment building.
I doubt my speakers have the power needed for that seat-shaking experience I had in the cinema.
One of the biggest reasons I'd love to move to a house is so I can upgrade my sound system without disturbing neighbors. If only they were affordable anywhere near my friends and family.
Already on my Jellyfin server mate.