Atheism

1662 readers

1 users here now

Be respectful to other members Treat others with kindness and courtesy, even if you disagree with their opinions.
Stay on topic Keep your discussions relevant to the purpose of the forum. Avoid going off-topic or derailing conversations.
No spamming Avoid posting irrelevant or unnecessary content, advertisements, or links to unrelated websites.
Use proper language and tone Choose your words carefully when commenting or replying to others. Avoid using profanity or engaging in offensive language and personal attacks.
Do not share personal information Protect your privacy by refraining from sharing personal details such as addresses, phone numbers, or email addresses on the forum.
Report any issues If you come across any inappropriate behavior or content, report it to the forum moderators or administrators.
Have fun and contribute positively Participate actively and add value to the discussions. Engage in meaningful and constructive conversations with fellow members.

founded 1 year ago

MODERATORS

[email protected]

Isn't religion really just an opinion? (sh.itjust.works)

submitted 8 months ago* (last edited 8 months ago) by [email protected] to c/[email protected]

44 comments fedilink hide all child comments

So, recently I was talking to a friend and somehow we got to talking about religion and stuff. When I complained that religion is often put on a huge pedestal and that it's really just a glorified opinion and should be subject to the same criticism as any other opinion, they told me that that was a really hot take.

According to them, belief and religion is more than just an opinion since it's such a big part of people's lives. I countered that opinions are also big parts of people's lives and personalities. I mean, a huge chunk of your personality is based on your opinions, right?

We agreed to disagree but I kept thinking about it. I don't get why religion shouldn't just be treated like any other opinion just because people tend to cling to it. I get that ~~it~~ people are emotionally invested but that's not just the case with religion but other opinions too. I would appreciate your thoughts to help me understand better, is it really a hot take?

you are viewing a single comment's thread
view the rest of the comments

[–] [email protected] 2 points 8 months ago

I agree that 'opinion' is a bad term, but 'belief system', while wildly used, is hiding its true nature, which believers do not want to and often cannot confront because of the high cognitive dissonance it would cause. I think there is no one word to accurately describe it. My attempt to put it in one sentence is: a shared delusion by indoctrination that fills a mental space that people have varying degrees of natural predisposition for.

All of the parts are important and all of them contradict the 'just another opinion' stance.

Shared: because religion and/or belief is inherently irrational, it helps if a lot of people or at least a significant portion of a person's community have the 'same' beliefs because it gives them perceived validity.

Indoctrination: to achieve the previous point, it is important to instill the beliefs in children, so 'optimally' they are perceived as natural and not questioned.

Natural predisposition: there's plenty of evidence, that there are specific regions in the brain which are active in believers, when they pray or partake in rituals. No matter the religion. This can also be true for people who are not part of any formal religion, but 'tap into' this spiritual part of the brain by meditation or other personal means. Then again, there are people where these regions are 'dead'/not there. And as always with humans: it is a spectrum.

Delusional: the 'core tenet' of belief is the acceptance of certain statements at face value against any amount of contradicting information, which is enabled by all the previous points.

So, how does this contrast with opinions? Anybody can have or form an opinion on anything. For any given subject there is a set of information for which a subset is available to an individual. This subset gets sorted, weighted, and filtered based on individual acquired discriminators. Those discriminators can come from all sorts of stuff, including education and religion. The available information as well as the sorting, weighting, and filtering can change over time and lead an individual to drastically reform their opinions. That is less likely (figuratively impossible) with a belief.

So, while it is possible to have religiously 'informed' opinions, they are very different in their nature from beliefs. And the word 'belief system' does not deny, but hides the mechanics that diferentiates opinions from beliefs.

(imho)