love my Oma, she's turning 90 next week (born 1934!) and was the first person I came out as bi to. Defo hanging one or two of these up in my dorm
Whenever people imply communism = lack of incentive for human greatness, I think about how my grandparents had lower class parents and were extremely poor (even starving) in their post-war childhood, but ended up leading pretty impressive lives, despite knowing they wouldn't live much above the material reality of their neighbors for it.
My grandma was an interior architect and my grandpa an astrophysics professor and professional photographer. Both were gymnasts in their 20's (my grandpa has a couple medals below). They didn't do any of that shit for luxury, they figured they'd lead a modest life in the standard plattenblau housing block as the other working people of their town (small but cute and cozy apartment, I was there not too long ago), and that's what they wanted.
They never needed to drive a car in their lives, and often visited countries across the Eastern Bloc by bike/public transit. My grandma always had a thing for making fruit preserves and cool pottery (still killing it), and my grandpa for art from wood carving (he was also a mountain climber). They had a nice community garden they always tended to too. It's a beautiful town with a lot to see, honestly can't wait to visit again
My mom was 19 when the Berlin Wall fell. She studied english abroad when everything went to shit under capitalism. Ended up moving to the US just because she met my dad. Usually when she tells an American she grew up in the DDR, they look all shocked and ask some insane shit like if she was starving to death, or if she knew anyone who was shot and killed trying to climb the wall (๐โ๏ธ). Certainly no one was starving by the 70s/80s. My mom and all her friends and acquaintances had great childhoods. She had a small town, middle of nowhere school system that pushed sports, music, art, multilingualism, sciences, etc. on her heavily (when I did track and field in high school she always told me how her school's facility was 10x better lmao). The DDR fostered genuine human greatness. But ig they didn't have bananas at grocery stores and a hundred car brands like the west ๐คทโโ๏ธ
Then please show me west german colonies. Both east and west germany might have benefitted from their colonial past in which both were involved. To my knowledge germany lost all of it's colonies in first world war. Also why do you think the GDR was not a puppet state itself?
Also hot Take: Mods removing my comment but not others which aim to be insulting on a personal level is problematic.
The US government pumped West germany with reconstruction money which in turn came from mass exploitation of any part of the world that could not resist it. Also, please note that Germany still has many American military bases, Germany is a puppet state and the money the US pumped into it wasn't done out of good will and the greatness of capitalism. It doesnt matter if it does or doesnt have a colonies itself its a willing participant in the oppression of the global south and is a dog of the US.
No one cares. This isnt the place to humor liberalism.
But the US does still pay a lot of countrys aid. Does that make them colonialist? Every country on the list in the link down below?
https://www.usnews.com/news/best-countries/articles/countries-that-receive-the-most-foreign-aid-from-the-u-s
And I think there has to be more influence in a country than some military bases to be a puppet state. See list of US military bases: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_American_military_installations All of them puppet states?
I am unsure what you want to say with your last sentences, but I am sure that you do not speak for all people. So a sentence like "No one cares." is just ignorant and dishonest. :)
Yes exactly, what do you think happens if those countries suddenly remove those American military bases?
I think this differs very much from the term puppet state. If there has been some agreement you can not easily draw back, this is clear.
Definition of puppet state from Wikipedia: "Puppet governments are usually kept in power by military force provided by an occupying country and are strongly controlled."
So please prove that all of the countries, in which the US hast Military bases, have governments which are only upheld by the force of US military.
Also, a lot of countries have Military bases in different countries. Are all of these countries now automatically puppet states? https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_countries_with_overseas_military_bases
You can also see in this list, that Germany has another active Military Base from UK. Please decide now to which country Germany is a puppet state, UK or US? Oh and France has one, too. Maybe Germany is governed by France? All of them?
All of them, why are you being so naive?
Its a western bloc run by the US, all of these countries went to Iraq when they had zero reason to go
Okay, my comments are getting removed again. For what exactly, mods?
Probably being a bad faith liberal with a nazi grandpa
Oh wow, are we now at just throwing insults, because you are in lack of arguments? Look at you, you must be proud of yourself for not understanding "No, he was no Nazi" and your firm worldview which can not handle a disussion with some rando on the internet.
Im not trying to reenact reddit here with you liberal
But you did. I did not even start to discuss with you specifically. Could have ignored me.
I guess i lost interest after you started defending western imperialist nations and your nazi grandpa
Why even start?
Bonus points for bringing forth the same insult again and again.
Im not here to argue with you or anyone for that matter this is my space, i dont care about your opinion, you can hear mine but please shut the fuck up otherwise
No :) Wanna insult my gramps again maybe?
No i dont care anymore
Okay nice, have a nice evening.
No
To frame my answer differently:
How is it naive not to believe someone on the internet who isn't even backing up arguments with sources?
Also: Please show me participation of germany in iraq war.
And please answer to my argument of the military backed government. If you do not accept the definition of puppet state I posted, please provide another.
Furthermore: You do not need to be a puppet state to go to war together. You can simply be allies or have the same interests.
Do yourself a favour and look up what happened when the Australian PM tried to close the Pine Gap military base.
I am always very much in favor of people providing their spources themselves, if they want to make a Point.
Here's a couple to get you started :)
1
2
If reading ain't your speed, this video has some background on it (as well as a list of sources in the description).
I found a YouTube link in your comment. Here are links to the same video on alternative frontends that protect your privacy:
Hey thanks for the Ressources. Gonna give them a try this evening or tomorrow.
No problem.