13
submitted 7 months ago by [email protected] to c/[email protected]

I’m looking for a better TTRPG experience. Started with AD&D in satanic panic era, left, came back to 5E a half dozen years ago. Got a great group & GM but some things just don’t suit me. For one, wouldn’t mind being done with Hasbro. My biggest issues in D&D? Character regret, & swinginess. Rolling up a character idea that sounds fun, but in-game always seems to go some completely different direction & now I’ve got an established character everyone depends on but locked into an un-fun stat / ability set. And ALWAYS whatever my concept is I can’t seem to roll for crap in those stats even with the bonuses, failing check after check when it’s the one thing I should be good at. That should only be possible rarely IMHO. Goals: I want above to go away or be much weaker. I want to be able to introduce friends & family who are new & unsure, probably rules light? But I do like dice rolling & some structure, don’t know if a pure storytelling game would work. Can’t be purely abstract. I love a good campaign but also a lot of times just want to be a beer league player, sit down, go to a cave & smash stuff, without needing a complex story to it. Party needs gold, rescue the missing turtle, let’s get swinging. Have thought for a long time about maybe west marches type scenarios. Show up, solve problems, check boxes, bring a new sheet to the next game whenever. Would work great for some of the gang. Not at all adverse to player death. Sorry so long, love to hear opinions!

you are viewing a single comment's thread
view the rest of the comments
[-] [email protected] 1 points 7 months ago

In the original rules failing a survival roll meant your character died, yes, start over. This was (justly) derided by most. Very rapidly, though, this was amended in subsequent rules to be a choice between character death and character being forced to muster out mid-tour by injury with no skill roll (yes, you still got skills randomly…). (This was later changed to be only the injury, IIRC.)

As a fix it replaced one ludicrous scenario with another: the character who was forced to muster out due to a failed survival roll in their first tour, leaving a character with zero skills, for all practical purposes.

this post was submitted on 13 Feb 2024
13 points (100.0% liked)

What Should I Play?

470 readers
1 users here now

founded 1 year ago
MODERATORS