From this thread over on /r/leftypiece where I've been arguing with vaushites who are currently trying to push people against this.
this post was submitted on 14 Jan 2024
52 points (100.0% liked)
anime
10890 readers
36 users here now
Welcome to c/anime on Hexbear!
A leftist general anime community for discussion and memes.
Simple rules
-
Be nice.
-
Use spoiler tags.
-
Don't sexualise underage characters, including 1000 year old loli ones.
-
Don't post hentai here. This is an anime community.
High quality threads you should definitely visit
Gigathread: Good Anime Talks, Presentations, Conventions, Panels, etc
Piracy is good and you should do more of it. Use https://9anime.to/ and https://4anime.to/ for streaming, and https://nyaa.si/ for torrents. Piracy is the only means of digital protest that audiences have to fight poor worker treatment.
founded 4 years ago
MODERATORS
you are viewing a single comment's thread
view the rest of the comments
view the rest of the comments
fishman island is about what if malcolm x assassinated mlk and falsely blamed white people for it to get more people to become reverse racist (which is a real thing in this scenario i guess)
Like, I really really like that the moral of the story is that "racism can arise just from the ambient culture, if inherent biases are left unchecked and unchallenged" but man was this the clumsiest metaphor to do that with, Oda really bit off more than he could chew here
yeah oda was absolutely not qualified to tell a story about race and so he defaults to using standard shonen manga style "ahh, the cycle of violence must be stopped," which is basically what he does in skypeia as well
in general, while oda is way ahead of most of his peers in most areas (trans rights included these days, but also he was so far below the curve there for a long while so i'm not going to give him any credit there) he's still a kinda lib guy making an incredibly mainstream piece of serialized art on strict deadlines and i think the number of people acting like it's the most radical piece of art in anime spaces only hurts it
i'm not opposed to allegory (i fucking love revolutionary girl utena, a show that has an insert song that ends with a choir singing "ALLEGORY! ALLEGORIER! ALLEGORIEST!") but when your allegory for political change ends with the rightful king restored almost every single time (including the rightful king of a settler colonial state, the indigenous people of which are leading guerilla warfare against!) i think that the allegory is broken
Yeah, that's a fair criticism of One Piece.
I think it's less that it's the most radical as much as it's the most accessible- enough people are familiar with shonen as a genre that they'll immediately "get" what One Piece is about, and having one of the Big Three Shonen Jump titles have even the slightest whiff of left-leaning politics in there gets it inordinately recommended as the "Baby Leftists First Anime" over, (sad to say) shows like Kaiji or Utena. Which is fine, I guess, if it's a pipeline to somewhere, but maybe the problem is 1) people aren't aware of other shows with more radical politics (and to be fair there's got to be only a handful, I'm struggling to name radical leftists movies off the top of my head, never mind cartoons) and 2) people aren't well-read enough on theory so they can't see One Piece's flaws in that regard
yeah i get why it happens, but it makes me like it a lot less than i otherwise would (though i still like it a lot!)
also if you want an openly leftist anime that has zero allegory, watch dallos. it was the first ova, it's directed by mamoru oshii (of ghost in the shell and patlabor fame) and it's just straight up doing the battle of algiers but in space. it rules, the ending is incredible
Cool, will give it a look. I need to go rewatch Patlabor 2 sometime soon anyway haha
Terry Pratchett did "the rightful king" trope the best. The rightful king is such a good and decent and wonderful person that he rejects kingship, hides all proof of there being a rightful heir and fights against people trying to make him a king, because kings are inherently bad
I read fisher tiger as the Malcolm X stand-in. the dude raising an army in fishman island is a rando warlord (in our sense of the term, not diagetic).