468
submitted 10 months ago* (last edited 10 months ago) by [email protected] to c/[email protected]
you are viewing a single comment's thread
view the rest of the comments
[-] [email protected] 6 points 10 months ago* (last edited 10 months ago)

Talking about death of the author, I think I came across the furthest possible extent of it

There's an ancient Sumerian...joke? adage? parable? anecdote? That has gotten some attention in the usual places you'd imagine around the internet. Translated to English it says:

A dog walks into a bar and says "I can't see a thing, I'll open this one."

It's built like a joke, but if it was one the humorous element has been lost to time. No one gets it. Not even archaeologists. Hypotheses include:

  • It's an aural pun for a language we no longer know how to pronounce. Imagine archaeologists in the year 6000 puzzling over "What's black and white and red all over? A newspaper." That joke already doesn't work in written English because even a native English speaker might not get the pun if they first encountered the joke in print rather than spoken aloud, because the homophones aren't spelled the same.

  • It's a vocabulary pun that we no longer understand. "A man walks into a bar. The next man ducks." Is just a non-sequitur unless you understand that the phrase "walks into a bar" means both "entered a drinking establishment" and "collided with a horizontal metal rod." Does one or more of the words in the joke carry an additional meaning that has been lost to time?

  • It requires some cultural understanding that we lack. "A man walked into a wiring closet, and was shocked by what he saw." If those future archaeologists reading this joke with no other context don't understand what electricity is, it will be impenetrable to them. There is apparently a hypothesis that Sumerian bars doubled as brothels, so it's a joke about a dog peeking at people fucking.

We talk about "death of the author" in terms of, the author meant something while writing the work, the work means something to the audience when they read it, sometimes these two meanings are different, which of the two meanings is correct/matters? People have read all sorts of meanings into the cockatoo screeching in Citizen Kane; in an interview Orson Welles says the cockatoo was there simply to wake up the audience. If you do find meaning there where none was intended, is that meaning valid?

The person who wrote the above joke has been dead twice as long as Jesus. We don't know their identity and have no metatextual writings from them; no explanation of what this meant to them. We have no way to ask the author what he meant by this, and we don't get the joke. We can read the text and understand its surface level meaning, and that's it.

So...what now?

[-] [email protected] 1 points 10 months ago

Cool story bro. I do mean that sincerely, it has the sort of energy that made me want to say that, but I am genuinely glad to have now heard that story, it's pretty interesting

My first thought was it might be a non sequitur, but it seems like it has too much structure for that or to be the earliest recorded troll.

What I find fascinating is that we might find the answer - language has math, AI research has made us start looking at language as high dimensional shapes in information space. Turns out, not only do languages have a consistent rate of information expression when spoken, but there's a common human shape to language

Having just a few examples of writing and distance in time makes it harder, but with the combinations of studying language evolution (they have shockingly clever methods with a solid mathematical basis) and the many things we're learning about the math of language (now that we've discovered it's incredibly important technologically)...

We might understand the joke one day, maybe even soon. Or maybe we won't, because not enough information remains to definitely declare an answer. Or maybe this is the first troll, and over time more humans that had ever existed when the author wrote it will spend lifetimes trying to understand this weird, unsolved language puzzle.

Maybe, as humans grow in number and specialize more and more, this specific joke spawns multiple fields of study

Regardless, that dude was epic.

this post was submitted on 27 Oct 2023
468 points (98.5% liked)

tumblr

3309 readers
1 users here now

Welcome to /c/tumblr, a place for all your tumblr screenshots and news.

Our Rules:

  1. Keep it civil. We're all people here. Be respectful to one another.

  2. No sexism, racism, homophobia, transphobia or any other flavor of bigotry. I should not need to explain this one.

  3. Must be tumblr related. This one is kind of a given.

  4. Try not to repost anything posted within the past month. Beyond that, go for it. Not everyone is on every site all the time.

  5. No unnecessary negativity. Just because you don't like a thing doesn't mean that you need to spend the entire comment section complaining about said thing. Just downvote and move on.


Sister Communities:

founded 1 year ago
MODERATORS