this post was submitted on 30 Sep 2023
10 points (100.0% liked)
Dota 2
1024 readers
1 users here now
founded 3 years ago
MODERATORS
you are viewing a single comment's thread
view the rest of the comments
view the rest of the comments
So I actually looked at all games from the perspective of the players you have a problem with. I can definitely understand how you did not have fun there, those games did indeed seem to suck. However, I do have a bit of a different outlook on the games, and I'm pretty sure they wouldn't have bothered me most of the time, so maybe it is my perception which has an issue :D But definitely kudos to you for actually providing replays, most of the time when someone makes these kind of posts, they don't, which I always find suspicious.
G1, you can't see team chat/voice in replays so I don't know what happened there... But what I do know is that Axe is playing against a dual melee lane and a 4 melee enemy team, as one of the offlaners most well known to shit on melees. It was theoretically kinda necessary that VS went top, having a dual melee against him is a death sentence, this match was bound to be a loss even if no one would have blamed each other. From what I saw in the replay, the Sven played decently well, Treant though indeed looked like he mentally gave up pretty early, ~10 mins, though he tried at least most of the time.
If I was in that game, I probably would've just muted on the very first instant they started flaming each other (depending on how bad it was) and then would've probably had an acceptable game, even though a loss most likely.
G2, I mean at least it was an even 4v4... who knows why they abandoned but both didn't look like rage quits or anything, probably something came up in their lives like unreliable internet or whatever.
This just wouldn't have bothered me at all, when someone abandons out of the blue like that I never assume bad intentions, life just happens sometimes. If it's a 4v5 it sucks but nothing to be done, but in a 4v4 I wouldn't even have said it sucks, just a fun new experience, I mean how often do you get to play dota 4v4 :D
G3, of course Magnus is too passive, WR was almost useless as a support :D however one interesting thing I noticed... when she was killed the first time at 13 minutes, WR muted/reported Centaur, which was you. Now of course I don't know what was said there, if you were responding or whatever, but it shows me that you don't seem to have the best reactions against these types of players. Honestly, except for leaving the lane, the alternative things she did were actually all pretty good up until that point. Only after she muted/reported you did I notice that things went downhill in her gameplay, and I see the behavior you complain about.
Honestly... just mute and move on. Again, I have no idea what actually happened, but the fact that WR muted/reported you means that you didn't just mute and move on, but argued with her on some level. Engaging with these players almost never helps, even if "they started it". And mostly it hurts even more, like it seems to have in this case.
G4 I mean Crystal Maiden mid :D to me this looks like an all-role-queuer who usually gets only support who was suddenly thrust into mid one game, not really expecting it. Even going support, not mid, items. I mean she honestly didn't do terribly until like 10 minutes, but then you of course notice that you don't have a midlaner in the game, but 3 supports.
Very unfortunate imo. CM probably shouldn't have queued mid, but "all roles" has been pretty standard amongst support players for a long time now, almost never getting a core role. As an "all role"-queuer myself, I also recently noticed that I actually got a lot of mid and offlane, which probably takes a while for support players to adjust, i.e. actually changing to only queuing support.
G5 In general, OD is an absolute lane dominator 1v1, so the lane is supposed to be lost if not helped. Not against sniper, weirdly enough, but Sniper had no idea how you need to play against OD. So 1. mid was not helped by anyone, so it would've been a loss normally anyway, and 2. Sniper didn't know how to play against OD.
But what stands out to me more is that your lineup was extremely bad early game with a really good lategame, while theirs was an extremely good early game with a bad lategame. But your team played as if they had a good early game, trying to fight, while you needed to dodge fights as much as possible to have a chance to get to the lategame. I'd just call that an outdraft in general, but I think it could have been winnable if the supports helped against OD mid which is usually necessary and then everyone just tried to shove lanes and dodge fights, but yeah, it would have always been miserable the first 30 minutes.
G6 that was a disaster :D both Lich and Necro fed Pudge like crazy. And the snowball just kept rolling, it kept getting worse. Honestly Lich was doing the right thing in general, trying to defend the lane when Necro went into jungle (which was also quite a bit of a grief), but of course just kept feeding more since he was still playing badly and now also frustrated.
Funnily enough Lich also muted/reported you 6 minutes in. I'm sorry to say it, but I sense a pattern... Yeah, Lich sucked, and yeah, as you said, they were probably swearing the team. But just mute them and move on, don't engage and make it worse.
In total, yeah, not the best bout of dota you've had, I'm sorry for that :( Definitely bad luck to have so many in a row. But I also have to say that it seems like the games could have been much better with a different mindset, especially "mute and try to move on" is just ultimately so helpful in these instances. Try to have some fun doing weird shit after that, even though it's most likely a loss.
G2 was actually a 4x5, later WK came back and finished the game.
About G3, I just cannot agree. WR left the lane at 3 min, Magnus was dived at min 5, her TP was not on cooldown, and she missed a kill on lion at minute 6:40, but she just refused to play with Magnus. I don't remember what I have said but yeah, I usually interact with ppl during matches, maybe it is my fault, earlier I was very worried of her soaking XP from other lanes while Magnus was not able to get a level advantage as well.
G4 and G5 were not horrible toxic, CM was very salty but manageable and Sniper was just a dude, but the gap was so big it was annoying.
About G6 and G3, I don't understand how it was ok for WR on G3 to leave a drawn lane at min 3, but Lich here is right trying to defend a tower alone and getting 0/7 in 6 minutes, for me is the exact opposite, I even remember asking him to leave the lane, maybe we should have switched idk, this game would be hard anyway
But I agree with the point of just mute and move on, should do it more.
I'm not saying they did the right thing, I'm sayind considering the circumstances, they tried their best. Remember how you said there were griefers in all your games. I saw 0 griefers, only angry people making bad decisions and venting their anger.
What I saw when spectating them was bad plays, not intentionally throwing. WR was convinced Magnus can't be helped, if you exclude not going to Magnus, the rest of the stuff she did seemed fine, but of course she shouldn't have given up on Magnus. Lich could've actually survived in lane, at least gotten XP and defended the tower relatively long by pulling the creeps back, but of course not in the way he did it, he just kept dieing. But none of the deaths looked intentional.
I know I'm often playing badly, making the wrong decisions, so why should I care when others do the same, no matter the reason? Sure, getting angry and flaming is bad, but I also sometimes get the urge, it's a natural, albeit bad, thing.