this post was submitted on 02 Sep 2023
846 points (87.2% liked)
Memes
45731 readers
1114 users here now
Rules:
- Be civil and nice.
- Try not to excessively repost, as a rule of thumb, wait at least 2 months to do it if you have to.
founded 5 years ago
MODERATORS
you are viewing a single comment's thread
view the rest of the comments
view the rest of the comments
Wow. I guess someone has never actually read Trotsky or anything from Trotskyist. Try some Tony Cliff. Also, how you think Trotskyist sound today is not an indictment of Trotsky. Being critical of a revolution that has failed and the leaders and politics that followed is not the crime you think it is.
Jesus fucking Christ this is not the revolutionary left we need. Grow the fuck up.
edit: That's funny, either you posted your edit while i was typing my response or I didn't see it some how. either way. I'm sorry for being such a dick. I'm just so fed up with folks online regarding, what i would call state capitalist countries as genuine socialism, and rejecting any criticism of said states, as capitalist loving trash. Somehow Marxism has become a ridged dogma for these people. With the campist and the tankies distorting revolutionary socialism so much i fell like i live in upside down world. again sorry comrade. I would suggest "the two souls of socialism". side note Trotsky was Lenin's pick as leader not Stalin. Had he not "defected" he would likely have been killed by Stalin much earlier, like many of the seasoned former Bolsheviks who lead and then tried to defend the revolution against Stalin.
In none of this exchange did you demonstrate a fraction of the knowledge as the person you're berating. You just genuinely don't seem to know anything except how to sound confident in an online argument. So I'm sorry but listening to you lament all the wayward academics and telling people to grow the fuck up just doesn't land. I think you're just full of shit.
I’m not gonna engage with you about Trotsky but holy fucking shit you’re the mythical “state capitalist” sayer who actually is a self aware cliffite.
It’s a pleasure to meet you!
E:
I see what you did there!
What kind of revolutionary left do you want? Regardless, wanting to hard-reboot an existing radical movement over its perceived "failure" - while it's still gaining traction - is what Trotsky did, and it just threw a wrench into things.
And not to be that guy, but the negativity isn't doing you favors. I made an effort to be reasonable and objective (except the Modern Trotskyites bit, since they honestly feel too sus and self-destructive to take seriously). If you're feeling threatened by that, idk what to tell you. This is just what we believe. No one pays us for it.
go read my edit
Read up on your Trotsky fool
I think there are more Ultras than Trots these days, this is like seeing a unicorn.