Commander

cross-posted from: https://lemmy.world/post/20424113

Tl;dw shamelessly stolen from Reddit:

• "We all, WOTC and RC, reached this conclusion together."
• They are taking precautions to ensure the safety of RC members.
• They still want to keep it a community-driven format.
• Gavin plans to establish a committee similar to Pauper Format Panel. RC and CAG members are likely members.
• Aaron addresses the worries about profit-driven actions. "I'm also here for the love of the game(like RC).Yes Hasbro wants things. Yes my bosses wants things. I have a lot of freedom to do what I think is best. Our goal is to make things last forever. Keeping the community happy is our way to make money."
• They want to wait until the Panel is established to talk about the banlist. Beyond the initial banlist changes they don't want to make changes too often.
• Quarterly banlist updates similar to RC. It won't follow B&R of other formats.
• Power brackets: E.g. tier 1 swords, tier 2 thalia, tier 3 drannith magistrate, tier 4 armageddon etc.
• Aaron Forsythe used to play Armageddon 😱
• They aren't trying to replace Rule 0, they are trying to make it easier.
• At least 1 person from the CEDH community will be part of the panel. WOTC will still focus on casual commander.
• No separate banlists. Brackets will already do that job.
• Aaron: "4th bracket will be cards that you will rarely see in precons."
• Sol Ring isn't going anywhere. Sol Ring is "Bracket 0" so to say.
• Points system similar to Canlander is too complex and competitive for casual commander.
• Brawl in Arena already separates decks into 4 categories.
• Jeweled Lotus, Arcane Signet, Dockside etc. were mistakes. Cards that were banned recently are the kinds of cards they wouldn't want to make today. They want to reduce ubiquitousness going forward.
• They are discussing implementing more digital tools. E.g. you enter your decklist and it tells you your bracket.
• They want to release first Brackets article before MagicCon Las Vegas.
• Committee will be in the range of 10-20 people. There are also 10 commander designers working in WOTC.
• They are not tied to number 4. They can make a 5th bracket for CEDH.
• It is undecided whether the Committee will be anonymous. At least some names will be known.
• They can divide combos into different brackets: Thoracle combos bracket 4, SangBond+EqBlood bracket 3 etc.
• Gavin reads reddit a lot.

Commander:

• Dockside Extortionist is banned.
• Jeweled Lotus is banned.
• Mana Crypt is banned.
• Nadu, Winged Wisdom is banned.

Hello o/

I've been an off and on magic player since highschool and after going to a draft felt the urge to try building a commander deck again. After having some fun brewing I saw that a new set called Bloomburrow is going to be released shortly. I looked through the set and was blown away by how powerful some of the cards are. A lot of them just seemlingly better versions of cards that I had slotted into the deck I was brewing. A spellslinger prowess deck built around Balmor, Battlemage Captain. Cards that surprised me were Stormcatcher mentor, Bria, Riptide Rogue, and Kitsa, Otterball Elite. To me they just seem so much better than any of the existing prowess cards.

To get to my actual question. How do you all deal with the power creep? Are people moving away from commander into other formats? Or do you just need to keep updating decks every few months with the new cards being printed?