this post was submitted on 09 Mar 2024
4 points (100.0% liked)

How Timeless are the Lyrics to ....

46 readers
2 users here now

A community which discusses the timeless of certain songs mostly based on their lyrics.

Imagine you were a timetraveller with incredible musical ability. How many years back could you go and sing a specific song in such a way that it would resonate the same way with the people back then.

How many words or phrases would you have to change to make it fit?

founded 1 year ago
MODERATORS
 

Lyrics: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=DPoW19TUfg8

Please, sir, tell me why there's no black Superman, KKK kryptonite?
"God only makes Caucasian super-heroes."
Please, sir, tell me why we stick a man on the moon when life on earth's so cheap?
"Son we gotta do our bit for the world trade deficit."

Please, sir
Please, sir
Tell me why
If "God is love," I'm so dysfunctional

Please, sir, tell me why there's so much vagrancy
"Layabouts get a job." - Well, there's an opening for a part-time Unabomber Please, sir, tell me why my life's so pitiful but "the future's so bright."
Well, I'd look ahead but it burns my retinas

Please, sir
Please, sir
Tell me why
If "God is love," I'm so dysfunctional

all 3 comments
sorted by: hot top controversial new old
[–] [email protected] 1 points 8 months ago* (last edited 8 months ago)

This song contains references to:

  1. Superman (1903)

  2. Superhero (1930)

  3. Kryptonite (1943)

  4. KKK (1878)

  5. Caucasian (1795)

    • Blumenbach's anthropological theory that man is distinguished into 5 races, based on skull similarity. Assigned "white" to Caucasian.
  6. God / "God is love" (Biblical origins)

  7. "If we can put a man on the moon..." (1962)

    • Phrase first used less than a year after President Kennedy announced the moon landing program, but then used by others soon after. Lowell Purdy coined the phrase to criticize Kennedy about the federal farm policy:
      • "Nothing is impossible in this age of miracles,” he said. “If we can put a man on the Moon, we surely are capable of seeing that our temporary surplus agricultural products are placed in many hungry stomachs of the world.”
    • https://www.fastcompany.com/90366583/the-wild-improbable-history-of-the-phrase-if-we-can-put-a-man-on-the-moon
  8. trade defecit (1540s)

  9. Dysfunctional (1915)

  10. vagrancy (1706)

  11. pitiful (1580s)

  12. layabouts (1932)

  13. job (1620)

  14. Part time (1891)

  15. Unabomber (1979)

  16. "future's so bright" / burn my retinas (1986)

Quick Assessment

At least late 80s for someone to get all the references, but someone from the 1915 would understand 50% of the references

Modifications

Verdict

Even with modifications, the "Future's so Bright" reference places this song firmly in the late 1980s.

Without that reference and the moon landing reference, this song could be understood by someone in 1915.

Otherwise, with all modifications, someone from 1706 could understand half the references.

[–] [email protected] 1 points 8 months ago

Www and Infotainment are such good albums. I saw them open for Static-X back in the 90s and it fucking ruled.