this post was submitted on 07 Mar 2024
45 points (100.0% liked)

Comics

210 readers
33 users here now

founded 1 year ago
MODERATORS
 

Alt text: Also I have the concept of moving capital from the unproductive landed gentry class into the hands of the industrialists who will use the surplus value to improve production, if you are interested. It mostly involves getting rid of people like you...

Author blurb: The Cotton Looms get all the press in the early industrial revolution, but the Threshing Machine really might be the biggest jump in productive capacity in the history of the world. It cut out so much manual labor (people used to have to bash flails against the grain for hours and hours to separate the seeds) that there were riots all over because it caused so much unemployment and social upheaval. The famous Luddites, who people think of as being opposed to all technology, were mostly mad about automated cotton looms, and their consequences on society. They even went so far as destroying the looms (and other similar movements destroyed threshing machines). They weren't just backwards thinking technology haters though, but rational people who noticed that there was something deeply wrong with how society was organized that a machine which improved efficiency so much was causing poverty and even starvation among the very workers who it should have benefited. It wasn't the Luddites who were irrational, but the structure of society itself. After all it should be the people doing back breaking work who are most happy about a machine replacing them, but because all efficiency gains go to the owners, those people are simply out of a job. We've seen this time and time again under capitalism, and is even going on right now with AI.

The dragon is based on Adam Smith, who noticed these kind of improvements in production were the key to increasing the wealth of a given society, and that reorganization of society from feudal lords, who largely spent their money on luxuries, to industrial capitalists, who spent a lot of their money on "research and development", i.e. improving the efficiency of their factories, was causing economic growth and ever increasing wealth. In order to modernize, societies essentially had to get rid of the feudal lords put all of their money into the hands of capitalists as much as possible, to kick start this kind of economic growth.

Link

top 1 comments
sorted by: hot top controversial new old
[–] [email protected] 4 points 8 months ago* (last edited 8 months ago)

The dragon is based on Adam Smith, who noticed these kind of improvements in production were the key to increasing the wealth of a given society, and that reorganization of society from feudal lords, who largely spent their money on luxuries, to industrial capitalists, who spent a lot of their money on "research and development", i.e. improving the efficiency of their factories, was causing economic growth and ever increasing wealth.

One thing that's lived in the back of my brain for a long time is the fear that we're reaching a kind of soft frontier on scientific research and economic development. Which is to say, because we can no longer garner these enormous economic improvements from these marginal infrastructure improvements, the incentive to throw enormous sums of money into new infrastructure is fading away.

This AI crazy failing to deliver instant explosive gains in productivity is illustrating a bunch of the problems plaguing industry going on for over a decade. And our inability/refusal to invest in transcontinental public projects only exacerbates the problems. Can't even get a HSR from LA to San Fransisco without pissing away billions of dollars and getting a second season mid-tier HBO mini-series about detectives to make fun of you.

Does this mean we're going back to the old style of Feudal Society, where billionaires just throw "White Parties" and compete to have the biggest yachts and take over social media companies out of pure vanity? Are we finally at the end of the industrial revolution and doomed to sink back into Bourbon Dynastic Rule?