The original post: /r/datahoarder by /u/zaxophone_bswv on 2025-01-03 03:59:13.
Hi all, I need some advice for digitizing old analog video, and after viewing several advice posts that are all several years old and not 100% applicable to my situation, I'm just not sure what route to go down.
After a lot of searching, I finally found a very important family video - a Maxwell Hi8 MP tape with the only video and audio recording that we have of my grandfather, in which he is telling his World War II stories. The camcorder we recorded it on (I was a child at the time, it really belonged to my parents) is nowhere to be found. We think it's somewhere in the house, but even if we could find it, we don't know if it still works. There is a possibility of more family Hi8 tapes showing up, but for now this tape with my grandfather is the only one I have on hand and is the singular most important tape for me to digitize.
I work in the historic preservation field, so usually capturing things in archival quality is highly important to me, so I've been interested in the DIY methods. However, the two problems are that (1. I just don't know if it's worth it to buy several hundred dollars of equipment for ONE tape versus just having a media conversion company handle it, and (2. There's so many different formats and interchanges and dongles that, after reading post after post, I still don't know what I actually need and what would work and how it would work.
What I'm dealing with now: My computer is a 2021 HP laptop running Windows 10 with USB, Thunderbolt 3, DisplayPort++, and HDMI ports, but no FireWire. I also have a curmudgeonly but reliable 2007 iMac that I revive every 3-4 years when I realize I forgot to get something off it, and it has a FireWire 400 port. I remember using FireWire all the time to port videos I made as a teenager using a MiniDV camcorder into iMovie. I think iMovie still works on it, maybe??
I read somewhere else that analog tapes like Hi8 are best converted using S-Video instead of FireWire for color quality reasons. It sounds like a good idea, but I don't know what equipment I need in order to go down this route either. Neither computer has an S-Video port and I don't know what would be the most compatible with that format.
And on top of this, I don't know what I need on the software end. I know the software ecosystem can change very quickly, so I just don't know what I can still trust from what I've read online.
So with all this considered, the advice I need:
Should I just send this to a company to digitize, and if so, who is reliable? Are there any catches?
Or if I should DIY, what are my options? What routes can I take, and how do I put those routes together for the most successful outcome?
Thanks in advance! And when it's all said and done, I'll share the video with you all (if the moderators here allow it).